Tobias G

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 362 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Tobias G
    Participant

    The sutta SN 56.35 says in the english translation: 100 spears and 3 times a day. That makes 300 spears a day.

    in reply to: Cetasika #29618
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Thank you, Lal!

    How can we understand ditthi cetasika? I thought ditthi is a concept word (not ultimate reality), that means “how someone sees the world”. But as asobhana cetasika it colors the citta in a certain way and it is part of the ultimate reality. Can I interpret: “with that ditthi-color one cannot correctly see the world”?

    in reply to: Post On Difference Between Rūpa and Rūpakkhandha #29347
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Namarupa are generated via PS. But they are rupa, thus they belong to rupakkhandha, correct? Of course all we have experienced in our lifes also belongs to rupakkhandha. In the case of namarupa they come back to the mind as vipaka vinnana. Based on that experience we can add more vinnana and generate stronger nama rupa (again via PS).

    in reply to: post on 37 Factors of Enlightenment #27451
    Tobias G
    Participant

    But in the text you write the 37 factors are cetasika. That should be corrected, too.

    in reply to: Clarification about the 31 realms #27255
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Regarding the second question (Nibbana) my answer: Existence in all realms is based on bondage to rupa. Nibbana follows if one cuts off the bondage to rupa. Thus Nibbana is not another realm.

    in reply to: post on Vinnana, Thoughts, and the Subconscious #27225
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Can you explain how to type these special letters for Tipitaka English, like the “a” with a line above?

    in reply to: post on Boy Who Remembered Pāli Suttas for 1500 Years #26748
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Are stupas closed chambers so that no human can go inside?

    Tobias G
    Participant

    Is there a PS sequence for functional behavior (kriya)?
    e.g. at work I have to think and take decisions. That also requires sankhara, vinnana, namarupa (visuals, concepts), phassa, vedana, neutral tanha, neutral upadana …leading to occupational bhava…jati..
    Thus ingredients of a PS cycle are involved.

    in reply to: Post on “31 Realms of Existence” #25967
    Tobias G
    Participant

    What is the cause for birth in the asanna realm?

    in reply to: Topic for inconsistencies on the site #25966
    Tobias G
    Participant

    I was searching trough the posts but cannot find the passages. So I explain it here.
    It is said several times here on the website that a gandhabba is under stress while staying in paralowa. On the other side I remember a doctor who was out of his physical body for some days (coma). He came to a “good location” in paralowa with a “partner” (which was actually his sister, as he found out later). So here we can see that it is not necessarily a stressful stay in paralowa. Also it can be that gandhabbas go into a dream like state which feels timeless. All together I would not say that gandhabbas are really stressed while in paralowa.

    in reply to: Post on “31 Realms of Existence” #25965
    Tobias G
    Participant

    I still search for the 8. Which 8?

    in reply to: Post on Kamma are Done with Sankhāra – Types of Sankhāra #25740
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Non, that is the problem. How can a punna kamma be done with avijja which is lower level moha (that is a cetasika)?

    in reply to: Post on Kamma are Done with Sankhāra – Types of Sankhāra #25736
    Tobias G
    Participant

    That is clear, but not in terms of Abhidhamma and cetasika. Punnabhisankhara should not contain asobhana cetasika.

    in reply to: Kamma are Done with Sankhāra – Types of Sankhāra #25713
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Hi Lal,
    on May 14 you wrote:
    “Yes. Moha is a cetasika. Avijja is not moha, but a reduced form of moha.

    When one does punna kamma, it is the avijja cetasika that is involved (unless one has comprehended Tilakkhana, in which case it becomes a punna kiriya, without kammic consequences).”

    Avijja is not a cetasika, moha is. Anyway, how can one do punna kamma with avijja, when this good act involves sobhana cetasika? Are the citta vithi mixed: sobhana/asobhana citta vithi?

    in reply to: post on What Reincarnates? – Concept of a Lifestream #25532
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Thank you, Lal. That makes sense. So jivita rupa are part of the kammaja kaya and sustain the life of the gandhabba.

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 362 total)