Tobias G

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 362 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Tobias G
    Participant
    1. Is cakkhu viññeyya rupa equal to nāmarūpa in PS?
    2. Which of the PS-steps correspond to kāma guna?
    Tobias G
    Participant

    If there are two types of vinnana (ajjhattaṁ / bahiddhā), how can this happen in a single citta (CV)? Or does it require two citta vithi?

    Tobias G
    Participant

    1. You say Cakkhu Viññāṇa: bahiddha and ajjhatta viññāṇa complete (PS: ‘avijjā paccayā saṅkhāra‘ and ‘saṅkhāra paccayā viññāna’ steps complete). Thus cakkhu vinnana actually consists of two vinnanas (bahiddha and ajjhatta)?

    2. In the sequence below, I cannot find the santirana citta mentioned. Where does it belong?

    Sampaṭicchana: ‘cakkhu viññeyya rupa‘ leading to generating ‘kāma guna‘ (rupa generated by the ‘cakkhu viññāṇa‘) leads to generating (samphassa-ja) vēdanā (PS: ‘viññāna paccayā nāmarūpa’, ‘nāmarūpa paccayā salāyatana’, ‘salāyatana paccayā (sam)phassō’, ‘(sam)phassa paccayā (samphassa-ja) vēdanā’ steps complete)

    Vottapana: PS: ‘(samphassa-ja) vēdanā paccayā taṇhā’, ‘taṇhā paccayā upādāna’. 

    3. How did you come up with these connections between PS, citta vitthi, and purana/nava kamma? Is this explained anywhere in the suttas? Or is that derived?

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Thank you for the clarification that viññāṇa paccayā nāmarūpa occurs at the Sampaṭicchana citta. I am still having difficulty mapping the early stages (kāma dhātu, bahiddha viññāṇa, and ajjhatta viññāṇa) onto both the Paṭicca Samuppāda sequence and the citta vīthi. Could you clarify the following:

    1. At which citta in the citta vīthi does the mind move from the kāma dhātu stage (with the initial mind-made rūpa and distorted kāma saññā) into the bahiddha viññāṇa stage? Does this happen already in the Pañcadvāravajjana citta, or only with the Cakkhu viññāṇa citta?
    2. In the Paṭicca Samuppāda sequence, where do the bahiddha viññāṇa and ajjhatta viññāṇa stages correspond?
      • Does bahiddha viññāṇa cover the steps from avijjā paccayā saṅkhāra up to viññāṇa paccayā nāmarūpa?
      • Does the transition to ajjhatta viññāṇa (and the conversion of indriya to āyatana) begin with the nāmarūpa paccayā saḷāyatana step?
    3. Since viññāṇa paccayā nāmarūpa takes place at the Sampaṭicchana citta, does that mean the bahiddha viññāṇa stage is completed by that point, while the ajjhatta viññāṇa stage (with saḷāyatana) begins at or after the Sampaṭicchana citta (e.g., during santīraṇa)?
    4. In the verse cakkhuñca paṭicca rūpe ca uppajjati cakkhu viññāṇaṃ, is the rūpe the mind-made rūpa of the bahiddha stage, and has the mind already left the kāma dhātu stage by this point?
    5. Does the same sequence apply when dhammā come directly to the mind-door (mano dvāra)? (kāma dhātu → bahiddha viññāṇa → ajjhatta viññāṇa)

    These points would help connect the citta vīthi, the early Paṭicca Samuppāda steps, and the bahiddha / ajjhatta description.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Tobias G
    Participant

    How is the Paṭicca Samuppāda process (especially Idappaccayatā) to be connected with the Abhidhamma sequence of a sensory input?

    Specifically: The pasāda rūpa receive the information from the external world and pass it to the hadaya vatthu (generating a hadaya rūpa = vibration of the hadaya vatthu lasting 17 citta). The mind receives the information.

    Question: Is the nāmarūpa in Paṭicca Samuppāda (at viññāṇa paccayā nāmarūpa) the first mind-made rūpa of this sensory event — or does an internal mind-made rūpa (with kāma saññā) already exist beforehand, to which the mind then reacts with avijjā paccayā saṅkhāra, thereby generating bahiddha viññāṇa?

    In the verse cakkhuñca paṭicca rūpe ca uppajjati cakkhu viññāṇaṃ — is the rūpe here already the mind-made rūpa of the bahiddha stage, or does that arise only afterward?

    I do not see this sequence clearly explained. Could you briefly clarify the order?

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Tobias G
    Participant

    reference: Pañca Indriya and Pañca Bala – Five Faculties and Five Powers

     

    While reading the Tipiṭaka I noticed several places in the Indriya Saṃyutta where the Buddha explicitly calls the paññā-indriya the agga (foremost) among the factors conducive to awakening. Since your post on the five faculties places a different emphasis, I wanted to share the key passages briefly.

    SN 48.67 (and 48.68–70):
    “Seyyathāpi, bhikkhave, ye keci jambudīpakā rukkhā, jambū tesaṃ aggamakkhāyati; evameva kho, bhikkhave, ye keci bodhipakkhiyā dhammā, paññindriyaṃ tesaṃ aggamakkhāyati, yadidaṃ – bodhāya.”

    SN 48.45:
    “Ekassa kho, bhikkhave, indriyassa bhāvitattā bahulīkatattā khīṇāsavo bhikkhu aññaṃ byākaroti … Katamassa ekassa? Paññindriyassa. Paññavato, bhikkhave, ariyasāvakassa tadanvayā saddhā saṇṭhāti, tadanvayaṃ vīriyaṃ saṇṭhāti, tadanvayā sati saṇṭhāti, tadanvayo samādhi saṇṭhāti.”

    SN 48.51 and SN 48.54 use similar comparisons (lion and elephant’s footprint) and again declare paññindriyaṃ … aggamakkhāyati.

    In AN 5.16 the same point is made for the five powers:
    “Imesaṃ kho, bhikkhave, pañcannaṃ balānaṃ etaṃ aggaṃ … yadidaṃ paññābalaṃ.”

    The suttas also speak of balance, yet these passages clearly present paññā as the “master indriya”.

    In light of this, the car simile on the page (with sati as the steering wheel and the other faculties as the wheels) might perhaps be adjusted to better reflect the special role of wisdom.

    From my own experience, many people also want to be mindful in a worldly sense, yet continue to wander around in the world because wisdom is lacking. Thus it makes sense that wisdom is placed in the driver’s seat.

    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58453
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Hello Lal,

    Can you please tell me in which section the post “Kusalamūla Paṭicca Samuppāda – Evidence Against It” is in?
    I think it is still linked to the main page.

    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58306
    Tobias G
    Participant

    So ‘kamma‘ means actions, speech, and thoughts that are based on raga, dosa, moha or alobha, adosa, amoha, and with avijja. 

    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58301
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Dear Lal, you say:

    1. In the Buddha Dhamma, ‘kamma‘ means actions, speech, and thoughts that are based on raga, dosa, or moha. Only those can lead to vipaka. 

    • Thus, they include punna kamma, apunna kamma, and akusala kamma….

    ——————–

    I thought punna kamma are done with alobha, adosa, amoha, and with avijja. Thus we have six roots leading to rebirth. Of course only akusala kamma leads to bad vipaka or downward path.

     

    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58296
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Can you please answer these questions?

    Above, you say: “…sankhāra generation ALWAYS leads to kamma accumulation.”

    Can one conclude from this that sankhara can only be performed with avijja and thus generate kamma (because: avijja paccaya sankhara)? 

    That would mean sankhāra are always connected with avijja. Thus, someone thinking while doing vipassana in satipatthana bhumi does not generate sankhāra, right? Therefore, the general equation sankhāra = “50 cetasika” only applies when avijja is involved. Is that right?

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58281
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Above you say: “…sankhāra generation ALWAYS leads to kamma accumulation.”

    Can one conclude from this that sankhara can only be performed with avijja and thus generate kamma (because: avijja paccaya sankhara)? Then the general statement that the 50 cetasika (without sanna and vedana) are sankhara would be false.

    It is certainly clear that asobhana cetasika lead to akusala sankhara/kamma, or rather, poor results.

    Sobhana cetasika bring good results in the form of punna kamma or magga phala (when paññā cetasika is involved).

    Punna kamma is still performed with avijja.

    in reply to: Contradictions in Paṭicca Samuppāda Vibhaṅga #58276
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Dear honorable Lal, thank you for this draft and addressing my question! It gives a good overview and much clarity. 

    Nevertheless, I would like to ask:

    So are you saying that Vb 6 in the Abhidhamma Pitaka is incorrect and/or was added later?

    Does that mean the Arahants were mistaken?

    It is said that the 50 cetasikas, except for sanna and vedana, are “sankhara”. Some of these are universal and occasional cetasikas, such as jivitindriya, manasikāra, or viriya. How, then, could these lead to new kamma?

    Furthermore, this text about cetasika says:

    “Viriya (effort) can become Sammā Vāyāma.“

    “Viriya and chanda are two factors in the four bases of mental power…”

    “Saddhā (faith);  sati (moral mindfulness) can become Sammā Sati” 

     

    How do you view the cetasikas of karunā and muditā?

     

    I’m still grappling with the question of how one actually thinks without external sensory input and without distorted sanna, or rather, how one arrives at genuine kusala citta? If the mind has no external sensory input (no panca-dvara citta vithi), one can only think about dhammas. In this way, one can have contact with sadhamma and, with appropriate “paccaya,” generate kusala citta and ultimately realize magga phala (e.g., during meditation). Is that correct? But this also requires cetasika; yet it isn’t paṭicca samuppāda?

    Tobias G
    Participant

    I’ve been thinking about why the Paṭicca Samuppāda (PS) process begins with avijjā, and this is the idea I’ve come up with:

    Avijjā is the root cause and the highest saṁyojana for our journey through samsara. Furthermore, the purana kamma stage begins with attachment to the altered rupa (bahiddha viññāṇa) for every being below the Arahant stage because of the presence of saṁyojana (at least avijjā saṁyojana).

    Both Arahants and puthujjanas experience kama sanna, or distorted perception. But the PS process begins only when there are remaining fetters. Therefore, avijjā is the minimum requirement for the start of Paṭicca Samuppāda. And the PS process applies to all sentient beings in samsara.

    Ultimately, of course, all parts of Paṭicca Samuppāda cease to arise once Arahantship is attained.

    Tobias G
    Participant

    This adds to the ideas above:  Consciousness Generates Space-Time

    “In a controversial 2025 paper, a researcher proposed a theory that consciousness may give rise to matter …“

    in reply to: Post on Ānāpāna – Adopting Buddha’s Worldview #57470
    Tobias G
    Participant

    Thank you, Lal! I agree with what you say. Understanding kama-sanna is an addition that helps to establish anicca-sanna.

    If Sanna is fundamentally 100% distorted and even an Arahant is constantly plagued by kamasanna, how can one become aware of the true nature? If we contact the world with our five senses, it will always fool us. People could also take the view that everything is illusion or simulation (natthi ayaṃ loko), so it doesn’t matter whether they purify their mind or not. Ultimately, the only remaining possibility is to develop wisdom and to realize the fruitlessness of existence (anatta).

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 362 total)