November 9, 2017; revised September 3, 2019
1. It is very important to understand the meaning of each term. The “defilement level” increases in the given order from kāma guna to kāmaccanda.
- Pronunciation of the terms:
2. In kāma lōka, we experience five types of physical sense inputs: pictures (rūpa rūpa), sounds, smells, tastes, and body touches. There are inherent “qualities” for each of these called “kāma guna“, and those are common to all of us in kāma lōka (actually they also depend on “bhava” and thus differ from humans to each type of animal, as we will discuss below).
- For example, all of us experience the sourness of lemon or sweetness of sugar (there may be defects in some people due to kamma vipāka).
- We all experience the unpleasantness of thunder or the pleasantness of music.
- While there could be minor differences, all humans experience the same basic “qualities” or ‘kāma guna” through the five physical senses. Even when one becomes an Arahant that will not change.
3. The 31 realms naturally exist to provide different levels of kamma vipāka according to the (abhi)sankhāra done in previous lives (mainly in the human realm; this is another topic that needs more background).
- The lowest four realms in kāma lōka (apāyas) have conditions that induce excessive suffering. Higher two realms in kāma lōka have rūpa rūpa, sadda, gandha, rasa, and pottabba that provide increasingly higher levels of “pleasures”.
- The rūpavācara brahma realms have rūpavācara jhānic pleasures; those brahmas had given up kāma rāga and had cultivated rūpavācara jhānas in previous human lives.
- Those in arūpavācara brahma realms had given up both kāma rāga and rūpa rāga and had cultivated arūpavācara jhāna in previous human lives.
- That is why kāma guna is absent in both rūpavācara and arūpavācara brahma realms. Those who are born in those realms had given up sense pleasures for jhānic pleasures.
4. Therefore, there are pleasing things in our kāma lōka (human realm) that naturally arise to provide sense pleasures according to abhisankhāra that led to births here. We all had craved sense pleasures in our previous lives, but had cultivated strong punna abhisankhāra. Those who developed strong apunna abhisankhāra (i.e., did immoral deeds to get such sense pleasures) are now in the apāyas.
- Thus, as humans, we are naturally exposed to those “kāma guna.” We are naturally “exposed to” sense objects that are “pleasing” to the five physical senses.
- Thus, if one has not comprehended the Tilakkhana then it is natural for one to get attached to such “pleasurable things.” Then one perceives that things in this world — including those things with kāma guna — can provide long-term happiness. But reality such cravings lead to suffering because those “pleasures” cannot be sustained.
5. Now, if a person gets attached to those sense inputs with kāma guna and starts generating greedy thoughts (generating vaci sankhāra) that is “kāma“. That is also called sankalpita rāga (generating sankalpanā that lead to samsāric journey).
- When one engages in sankalpita rāga (i.e., thinking greedy thoughts about such sense pleasures) that is generating vaci sankhāra. One is then likely to initiate kāya sankhāra too (start engaging in related physical activities.)
- That can happen to an average human. It can happen to a lesser extent to a Sōtapanna. That next step of intentionally generating sensual thoughts happens with kāma rāga. That will again reduce at the Sakadāgāmi stage and stopped only at the Anāgāmi stage.
- One cannot force the removal of kāma rāga. It will naturally go away when one changes one’s gati by Anāpāna and Satipathāna.
6. If not willfully controlled, kāma rāga can intensify to a point where one is capable of committing immoral deeds (hurting others or oneself.) One starts losing control when kāma rāga elevates to kāmaccanda level, the highest.
- That can happen to anyone below the Sōtapanna stage, i.e., one can be “blinded” by kāma, resulting in kāmaccanda (“kāma” + “icca” + “anda“, where icca is liking, and anda is blind, and thus “blinded by the craving for kāma“).
- Whether an average human will generate kāma, kāma rāga, or kāmaccanda depends on the strength of the sensory input and also on prevalent conditions. For example, if one’s mindset becomes degraded due to alcohol consumption, and one sees an attractive woman in an isolated setting, things could get out-of-control with kāmaccanda.
7. An Anāgami has removed kāma rāga but still has kāma, i.e., likes them somewhat.
- However, kāma of an Anāgāmi is not strong enough to lead to rebirth in the kāma lōka. In other words, an Anāgāmi will not generate abhisankhāra (strong sankhāra) for things with kāma guna (for example would have no desire to engage in sex).
- In the Abhidhammic language, an Anāgāmi has removed four greed-based cittas associated with wrong views. There are still “four greed-based cittas dissociated with wrong views”left. But they have lost much of the potency to move from the kāma to kāma rāga level; see #3 of, “Akusala Citta and Akusala Vipāka Citta.”
- Even that trace of kāma is removed only at the Arahant stage.
8. We can clarify with some examples. Sugar has a “kāma guna” of sweetness; that holds for everyone from an average person to an Arahant.
- A beautiful woman will be seen as such by anyone from an average person to an Arahant.
- An average person may generate kāma to kāmaccanda for that woman.
- A Sōtapanna may generate kāma to kāma rāga.
- An Anāgāmi may generate just kāma. But there is no “kāma rāga anusaya” left in him to go beyond that.
- But an Arahant will not generate kāma either.
9. The sight of such a woman is a kamma vipāka; for anyone (from an average person to an Arahant) still living in the human realm will see that she is beautiful.
- If one gets “interested” one generates kāma sankalpanā or vaci sankhāra; see, “Correct Meaning of Vacī Sankhāra.” Then it could lead to kāya sankhāra, i.e., turn one’s head to looks at her again with kāma rāga or kāmaccanda, that is a new kamma.
- A Sōtapanna still has “kāma rāga anusaya” left in him, and that is why he/she will return to the kāma lōka. He/she can be born as a human or dēva in the future.
- A Sakadāgāmi is in between the Sōtapanna and Anāgāmi stages. He/she will be reborn only in the dēva realms. Of course, an Anāgāmi will not be reborn anywhere in the kāma lōka.
10. Immoral actions done with kāmaccanda could lead to rebirth in the apāyas.
- Only kāma rāga –not kāmaccanda — can arise in a Sōtapanna. Thus he/she is released from the apāyas, but not from kāma lōka. A Sōtapanna is incapable of committing an “apāyagāmi deed” to satisfy any sensory pleasure.
- So, I hope you get the basic idea. The above reasoning applies to any of the five physical sense inputs.
11. Anyone born in the human realm will have similar “kāma guna” because they had cultivated corresponding “human sankhāra.” We all like the same things, and any variations we do have are due to the differences in those main sankhāra types.
- However, when it comes to animals, “kāma guna” can be much more different compared to humans or compared to other types of animals.
- Pigs eat very unpleasing things, including feces. Tigers or lions like to eat raw meat. Cows don’t like meat but like grass. The variations are quite apparent. Again those can be tied to sankhāra that they had cultivated as humans, and each bhava (and jāti) correspond to such sankhāra via paticca samuppāda. Some of you may be able to see that, but we will discuss this later.
- In brahma realms, things with kāma guna are absent. They were born in those realms because they had preferred and cultivated jhānic pleasures, instead of craving for sensual pleasures.
12. In that regard, we keep in mind for now that (abhi)sankhāra generated by humans have high javana power, and thus lead to various “bhava” and jāti. Animals cannot generate such citta with high javana power because of their bad birth. That is an important point. Animals pay for such past kamma until that kammic power is exhausted; see, “Javana of a Citta – The Root of Mental Power.”
- Even most dēvas or brahmas “go with the flow,” i.e., enjoy their kāma or jhānic pleasures that come with their birth, just as animals go through the suffering.
- It is only those dēvas/brahmas that had become at least Sōtapanna that would be motivated to strive for magga phala.
13. Therefore, it is mostly humans who can cultivate abhisankhāra (of both types) and thus make conditions for future “good births or bad births.” That is a critical point in the Agganna Sutta.
- All the animals that we see were humans in the beginning. Those with “bad gathi” that had been generated via “bad abhisankhāra” in their deep past, were reborn as various types of animals as the Earth evolved and conditions for animal life appeared.
- An introduction to Agganna Sutta is at “Buddhism and Evolution – Aggañña Sutta (DN 27)“.
14. Now let us briefly discuss a key sutta that is relevant. The “Nibbedhika Sutta (AN 6.63)” lists the five kāma guna:
“..Pañcime, bhikkhave, kāmaguṇā—cakkhuviññeyyā rūpā iṭṭhā kantā manāpā piyarūpā kāmūpasaṃhitā rajanīyā, sotaviññeyyā saddā … ghānaviññeyyā gandhā … jivhāviññeyyā rasā … kāyaviññeyyā phoṭṭhabbā iṭṭhā kantā manāpā piyarūpā kāmūpasaṃhitā rajanīyā. Api ca kho, bhikkhave, nete kāmā kāmaguṇā..”
Translated: “..Bhikkhus, there are five types with characteristics of sensuality (kāma guna). Which five? Forms are cognizable via the eye—agreeable, pleasing, charming, likable, desire-inducing, enticing. Sounds are cognizable via the ear. Aromas cognizable via the nose. Flavors cognizable via the tongue. Body sensations cognizable via the body—agreeable, pleasing, charming, likable, desire-inducing, enticing. But, Bhikkhus, these are not sensuality (kāma)..”.
- I have translated “guna” as “characteristics,” but it could be taken as “qualities” too.
15. Then the next verse of the sutta says what kāma is: “Saṅkapparāgō purisassa kāmō,
Nete kāmā yāni citrāni lōkē..”.
Translated: “a person’s kāma is getting attached and thinking about (sankappa rāga) those pleasing things in this world (citrani lōkē).” “Citra” (pronounced “chittra”) means a pleasing picture; “citrāni lōkē” here means “a world full of delightful things.”
To emphasize: There are many pleasing, delightful, enticing things in the kāma lōka. Just experiencing them is not kāma. One who has understood the real nature does not get attached to them. But those who do not yet understand the real anicca nature of things in the kāma lōka, value them highly. They crave them, and get a satisfaction (kāma assāda) by thinking about them (generating kāma sankalpanā or vaci sankhāra); that is kāma.
- It is essential to realize that conscious thinking or “talking to oneself” is vaci sankhāra; see, “Correct Meaning of Vacī Sankhāra.“
- Such vaci sankhāra can then lead to kāya sankhāra, whereby one takes actions to fulfill such desires (if one has kāma rāga anusaya).
- Some people go one step further and commit akusala kamma to fulfill such desires (then it becomes kāmaccanda).
16. Therefore, having the tendency to be attracted to sense inputs (i.e., the tendency to think about them and just getting a “good feeling”) is a natural outcome of being born in the kāma lōka; see, “Assāda, Ādīnava, Nissarana – Introduction.”
- And giving up that craving comes only with an understanding of the true nature (the anicca, dukkha, anatta nature), i.e., realize that they have adverse consequences; see, “How Perceived Pleasures (Assāda) lead to Dukkha.”
- Getting to the Sōtapanna stage means one has understood the dangers of kāma assāda. But one has not yet been “liberated” from them because one still tends to like them. However, a Sōtapanna will never do an immoral act to gain those sense pleasures.
- For a Sōtapanna to be free from such kāma assāda, he/she needs to contemplate the dangers (ādīnava) of kāma assāda as we discussed in the above two posts. That is what is called the “asubha bhāvanā.”
17. Many people misinterpret the asubha bhāvanā as to contemplate on disgusting things like rotting dead bodies. That is entirely wrong; such meditations only lead to patigha or “friction of the mind.”
- Instead, one needs to see that it is getting attached to those pleasing sensual things that lead to future suffering. Thus the real asubha (detrimental) things are those eye-pleasing, ear-pleasing, …body-pleasing things in this kāma lōka. One needs to contemplate on the harmful consequences/dangers of getting attached to them; see, “How Perceived Pleasures (Assāda) lead to Dukkha.”
- Therefore, it is not even possible to do the asubha bhāvanā correctly until one gets to the Sōtapanna stage. It is only then one begins to see the dangers in craving for sense pleasures.
- However, it is always good to cut down on sense pleasures, even while striving for the Sōtapanna stage. It makes one’s mind calm and susceptible to grasp more profound concepts.
- Extreme sense pleasures are a burden to the mind. It is possible to avoid those right now; see, “Satipattana Sutta – Relevance to Suffering in This Life.” Doing everything in moderation naturally leads to a simpler, healthier, and peaceful life.