Hemavata sutta

Welcome! Forums Sutta Interpretations Hemavata sutta

Viewing 5 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #19422
      upekkha100
      Participant

      http://usamyanmar.net/Buddha/Book/A%20DISCOURSE%20ON%20HEMAVATA%20SUTTA-Final.pdf

      Here are two paragraphs from the Hemavata sutta PDF:
      1) “The lady Kali who had acquired the divine hearing overheard the Deva’s (Yakkha) conversation, a special divine sense of hearing acquired by people who had accrued great parami in their past existence, also had attained Sotapanna after she developed her overwhelming adoration of the Buddha attributes. ”

      2) “The Satagiri Deva, unlike
      other Devas, although he was at the assembly, listening to the Dhammacakka Sutta, was not able to attain Sotapanna, because he was not attentive to the Sermon. When Satagiri and his friends Hemavata later met the Buddha, after hearing Buddha admonition had attained the Sotapanna along with their one thousand attendants Yakkhas. ”

      According to the above, Lady Kali became a Sotapanna from listening to a conversation between Satagiri and Hemavata. However, when Satagiri and Hemavata were having that conversation, they were not Sotapannas, they were still anariya for that entire conversation. They become Sotapanna only after meeting with the Buddha.

      My question:
      A desana does not necessarily have to be from an Ariya in order to attain the Sotapanna stage right? Because Lady Kali’s case shows that one can become a Sotapanna by listening to a desana from an anariya.

    • #19426
      Lal
      Keymaster

      Either Satagiri or Hemavata MUST have been a Sotapanna for Lady Kali to attain the Sotapanna stage by listening to their discussion.

      I do not have time to read the document. But something appears to be wrong with the above extractions from that document.

    • #19429
      Akvan
      Participant

      Hi Upekkha100,

      Is there a link to the original sutta?

      The one I found (https://suttacentral.net/snp1.9/en/mills) does not have any mention about Lady Kali. May be there is another sutta which has reference to it.

    • #19432
      upekkha100
      Participant

      Hi Akvan. I’m afraid I don’t have a link for the original sutta or any sutta related to this. Perhaps there are others who might know and can be of more assistance.

      Lal said:
      “But something appears to be wrong with the above extractions from that document. ”

      I think so too. Especially now after finding this from palikanon:
      http://www.palikanon.com/english/pali_names/sa/satagira.htm
      “Their conversation is found in the introductory gāthā of the Hemavata Sutta (q.v.). Buddhaghosa says (SNA.i.199) that, according to some, this meeting took place, not on the occasion of the first sermon, but later, when the Buddha was living in the Gotāmaka cetiya. “

    • #19459
      Christian
      Participant

      The good thing about that sutta is qualities of Buddha are explained very well which can really help Buddhanussati.

    • #19461
      SengKiat
      Moderator
Viewing 5 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.