May 13, 2018
1. Sammā Ditthi (or comprehension of Tilakkhana) is the necessary first step to start on the Noble Eightfold Path. If one has gained Sammā Ditthi (i.e., if one is a Sōtapanna/Sōtapanna Anugāmi), one would have understood the Four Noble Truths and can “see” (not with eyes, but with paññā) the path to Nibbāna:
- One has “seen” that there would be much suffering in future lives (especially in the apāyās), if one gets too much attached to worldly things by assuming that they can provide lasting happiness (this is the comprehension of the anicca nature).
- The reason for such future suffering is immoral actions, speech, and conscious thinking (kāya and vaci sankhāra done with ignorance or avijjā). This is why the first step in Paticca Samuppāda is “avijjā paccayā sankhāra“.
- That one can stop future suffering from arising by controlling one’s kāya and vaci sankhāra or to stay away from dasa akusala.
- And the way or path to accomplish that is the Noble Eightfold Path.
Those are the Four Noble Truths.
2. We can analyze it in a different way by first discussing what is meant by Nibbāna and also Sōtapanna.
- The Nibbāna Sutta in the Samyutta Nikāya clearly describes Nibbāna as, “..ragakkhayō, ōosakkhayō, mōhakkhaō, idan vuccathi Nibbānanthi“. That means Nibbāna is attained via removing greed, hate/anger, and ignorance from one’s mind.
- However, the step-by-step procedure to attain Nibbāna involves four steps, which remove four types of āsavās or mental fermentations that contaminate a mind; see, “The Way to Nibbāna – Removal of Āsavas“: Ditthāsava, kāmāsava, bhavāsava, and avijjāsava.
3. It is important to understand what āsavās or mental fermentations are, how they accumulate, and how they lead to grasping of a new bhava at the moment of death.
- Let us take an example. When one keeps doing immoral things based on greed (hurt others, steal, sexually misbehave, etc in order to satisfy that greed), then one’s mind accumulates “āsavās of greedy type”. “Mental fermentations” is a good translation for āsavā; it implies that the longer that one keeps them, they get more rotten.
- Another way to say that is to say one is cultivating “greedy gati“.
- This can be compared to adding rotten things to a pool of water. Contamination gets worse with time. Still, the dirt may settle down at the bottom of the pool, and the water may look relatively clean.
- However, when the water in disturbed, say by stirring with a long stick, some contaminants will come to the surface; that is anusaya. How much comes to the surface (anusaya) depends on how hard the water is stirred, i.e., how strong the sense input is. Furthermore, if there is a lot of dirt there, even the slight stirring can bring dirt up to the surface.
4. Asavas or mental fermentations are like mud at the bottom of the pool. When a mind has built up lot of āsavās accumulating deep inside, it is easier for them to come to the surface (i.e., for cravings to come to the mind) when one gets a corresponding sense input (seeing an attractive person, for example). This is called anusaya. So, how one responds in a given situation depends on those three parameters (gati, āsavā, anusaya), which are inter-connected : “Gathi (Gati), Anusaya, and Āsava“.
- Removal of these four types of āsavās (which is the same as removing corresponding gati) leads to the removal of 7 types of anusaya: ditthi, vicikiccā, kāma rāga, patigha, bhava rāga, māna, avijjā; see, “Conditions for the Four Stages of Nibbāna“.
5. The most important of the four āsavās is the ditthāsava. All other āsavās are influenced by the wrong views one has. When ditthāsava is removed at the Sōtapanna stage, 99+% of all “mental junk” or “mental fermentations” are removed from the mind.
- This is why the Buddha said that a Sōtapanna has removed an amount of defilements comparable to the soil in the whole Earth, and what is left in all three other types of āsavās can be compared to the amount of soil picked up by one’s thumb.
- Therefore, the hardest part is to get a clear idea of what is meant by Nibbāna, and see why that necessarily means getting out of the rebirth process, that is filled with so much suffering in the apāyās. The Buddha said that any given living being spends most of the rebirth process in the apāyās.
6. Therefore, the first, and most important step towards attaining Nibbāna is to remove ditthāsava, at which time the 2 types of anusaya and the 3 types of samyojana are also removed; see, “Conditions for the Four Stages of Nibbāna“:
- With the removal of ditthāsava leads to the removal of ditthi anusaya and vicikiccā anusaya.
- Simultaneously, the 3 samyojana (sakkāya ditthi, vicikiccā, silabbata parāmāsa) are also removed.
- We will discuss these in the next post.
- They are all removed by the “right vision” and that removal is called “dassanēna pahātabbā” or “removal via right vision”.
7. The hardest part to understand is what is meant by “right vision”. We have discussed at length at this website that it involves the comprehension of Tilakkhana (anicca, dukkha, anatta): That one cannot achieve long-lasting happiness by pursuing enticing things in this world, that one will be subjected to suffering in the long run if one does that, and therefore, such an approach will lead to one becoming helpless (especially when one is reborn in the apāyās).
- That is the basic “right vision” that must REGISTER in one’s mind. The truth of that needs to accepted by the mind.
- Just reading about this, and memorizing it is not enough.
8. Let us take an example to illustrate this point. There are people who do not believe in rebirth. That is a “wrong ditthi” or “wrong vision” according to the Buddha. But if one’s mind does not see that rebirth must be valid, just by reading about it is not going to change that impression in that mind.
- One should look at the evidence for rebirth with an open mind; see, “Evidence for Rebirth“. One should contemplate on the fact that nothing happens without causes, i.e., kammā will have vipaka. That in turn leads to the conclusion that rebirth must be valid.
- This is why getting rid of the 10 types of miccā ditthi MUST happen before one can comprehend Tilakkhana and become Sōtapanna. This was discussed by the Buddha in the “Mahā Chattārisaka Sutta (Discourse on the Great Forty)“.
9. One issue that I do not quite understand is there are some of those people who do not believe in rebirth, but want to attain the Sōtapanna stage and even the Arahant stage! They don’t realize the contradiction?
- By definition, one wants to attain the Sōtapanna stage in order to avoid births in the apāyās. So, if one does not believe in rebirth, why does one believe that it is possible to be born in the apāyās?
- We must also remember that even those of us who believe in rebirth, have been in this rebirth for a time which has no traceable beginning. Therefore, we must have also held such wrong views in the past. It is not easy to get rid of these 10 types of miccā ditthi.
10. In any case, we still need to have more clarification on what happens when one truly comprehends Tilakkhana.
- I think one good analogy is if one is wearing — say a blue-tinted glasses — all the time, then no matter how hard one tries, one WILL see the world see white objects as blue and other objects also distorted to appear with different colors.
- Removing a ditthi (or wrong vision) is like taking off those tinted glasses. It happens when one’s mind comes to a certain stage of understanding. This is cultivating paññā (wisdom).
- The only way to remove those “tinted glasses” is to contemplate on the teachings of the Buddha, and also to engage in puñña/kusala kammā that provide the conditions for the mind to comprehend those teachings.
11. A key factor that most people disregard is how much of a difference it can make in one’s mindset when one stays away from dasa akusala and engages actively in kusala/puñña kammā. One’s mind becomes clear and sharp, one will be able to comprehend deeper concepts easily; see, “Kusala and Akusala Kamma, Punna and Pāpa Kamma“.
- Then one will be able to get to get rid of the 10 types of miccā ditthi and then make the transition to the Noble Path by starting to comprehend Tilakkhana; see, “Sīla, Samādhi, Pannā to Pannā, sīla, Samādhi”.
- Comprehending Tilakkhana is different than learning mundane subjects like geometry or even mathematics. It can be difficult or relatively easier depending on how much “preparations” (dana, sila, bhāvanā) one has made in this life and also in previous lives; see, “Punna Kamma – Dāna, Sīla, Bhāvanā” and “Kusala and Akusala Kamma, Punna and Pāpa Kamma“.
12. As we discussed above, the key step in getting to the “right view” is for one’s mind to see the truth in the world view of the Buddha: That our world is much more complex than what we experience with our senses. That there are more realms of existence, that suffering is worst in those apāyās, and that unless we get rid of “apāyagāmi gati” one can end up in the apāyās.
- Those “apāyagāmi gati” are closely related to ditthāsava, which arise and accumulate due to ignorance of the Buddha’s world view or the real nature of the world (Tilakkhana).
- Furthermore, at the dying moment the mind can grasp such an apāyagāmi sense input (arammana).
- As we have discussed before, those things happen AUTOMATICALLY, based on one’s gati (āsavā). That is the important point to understand. Unless one is a Sōtapanna, those possibilities cannot be ruled out.
13. Another related key issue is not how many bad kammā beeja one has accumulated (some of which accumulated in previous lives and we are not even aware of them). Rather what is important is whether one’s mind will grasp a bhava (upādāna) in a given realm. That depends only on the level of paññā (wisdom) that one has cultivated and THEREFORE what kind of gati one has removed.
- It DOES NOT matter how many kammā beeja suitable to give rebirth in the apāyās are there. If one has removed “apāyagāmi gati” by cultivating paññā to the Sōtapanna stage, then one’s mind would not grasp such bhava.
- If one’s mind has removed all gati that can lead to rebirth in any realm, then one’s mind would not be able to grasp any bhava, and thus one would attain Parinibbāna at the dying moment.
- For example, Angulimāla killed 999 people, but was able to attain the Arahanthood within a week or so. Those bad kammā beeja were still there, but his mind would not grasp (upādāna) them.
14. When one gets to Sammā Ditthi (i.e., when one becomes at least a Sōtapanna Anugāmi), one’s gati have changed permanently. Since the next birth is according to one’s gati, one will not be born into a family with miccā ditthi. This is how it is guaranteed that one will have only 7 more bhava left.
- One may grasp Tilakkhana by focusing on one of them. But that will lead to comprehension of all three, and even more characteristics like the asubha (unfruitful) nature. They are all inter-related.
- Of course, there are different levels of Sammā Ditthi and it will be completed only at the Arahant stage.
15. Finally, there is no need to worry about whether one has attained a certain stage of Nibbāna. One should concentrate on following the Path. The Buddha said that if one follows Satipatthāna, one would attain at the least Anāgami stage within seven years (some earlier), if one has a tihetuka patisandhi.
- If one does not have a tihetuka patisandhi., the effort will not go waste, but will help attain Nibbāna in a future life.
- He said that if a framer plants seeds and takes good care of those plants, they will provide a good harvest. It is pointless to check each and every day to see whether the harvest is ready. It will happen in due time.