Alay

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Gandhabba and comatose state #21583
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Tien and Lal for your responses. It does make sense.

    Regards

    Alay

    in reply to: Schizophrenia and the mind #17684
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal for the explanation.
    I was discussing this with a retired Scientist (who is also on “the path”) and his explanation was similar – i.e due to the illness, the brain signals to the mind are “corrupt” and this causes various forms of images to be presented and would explain the resulting behaviour.

    in reply to: Gandhabba and physical characteristics #16745
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Akvan.

    in reply to: Gandhabba and physical characteristics #16722
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you for the explanation Lal.

    in reply to: From human to animal realm and back to human #16716
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you for your excellent explanation. Greatly appreciated.

    in reply to: Lobha, Dosa and Moha(?) in the animal realm #16268
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal. Excellent explanation! Greatly appreciate it.

    Kind regards

    Alay.

    in reply to: Clarification of definition – " anantariya" #16112
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal. It does make sense.

    Does the same apply to non-anantariya kamma too?

    I am assuming it is a complex relationship between cause and effect and not a one-to-one relationship.

    in reply to: Clarification of definition – " anantariya" #16108
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal.

    I was reading an article on Ven. Moggallana’s life. I was curious about the information regarding the passing away of Ven. Moggallana after being beaten by bandits. From what I understood, he killed his parents in a previous life.

    Ref: https://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/hecker/wheel263.html#ch9
    10. The Death of Maha Moggallana

    From your explanation, once a person commits an anantariya karma, the results follow at the end of the current life.

    Given the above, does the karmic energy from an anantariya karma get expended completely before being born in another plane? i.e. does the sentence have to be completed in full before another life form begins?

    According to Ven. Moggalana’s life, the kammic energy from the anatariya karma was still present as a result of which he was beaten by bandits.

    in reply to: Mental State/Demeanor of a Sotapanna #15981
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal.

    in reply to: Effect of thoughts when in Gandhabba state #15975
    Alay
    Participant

    Very good point Tobias. Thank you for the explanation.

    in reply to: Effect of thoughts when in Gandhabba state #15958
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal for the excellent explanation.
    So, essentially, once in the Gandhabba state, the thoughts (good or bad) of any human beings towards the life that he/she led do not have a bearing on where the Gandhabba ends up. It is only his/her own thoughts that determine the final destination?

    in reply to: Mental State/Demeanor of a Sotapanna #15947
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you Lal.
    I guess one should not have anger towards the person who is committing wrong (i.e. in most cases, we get angry seeing such actions and as a result, we take some action).

    in reply to: Mental State/Demeanor of a Sotapanna #15938
    Alay
    Participant

    Hi,
    How should an individual who is “on the path to Nibbana” respond in the following situations?

    A person blatantly breaks the law (could be stealing from a Supermarket, a home-invasion / breakin or could be in a parking lot where they crash another vehicle and take off etc..)

    Should the individual take any form of action or should they ignore the breaking of the law and drop the thoughts and move on? If they were to take some form of action (i.e. speak to the Manager about the stealing or speak to the owner of the house / damaged vehicle) does that belong to “dosakaya” or should any action taken be purely based on the rule of law with no dosa involved towards the law-breaker?

    in reply to: Clarification of Dosha (Dvesha) and Raga #15338
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you for the excellent clarification. Greatly appreciated.

    in reply to: Body, Gandhabba & vice-versa #14387
    Alay
    Participant

    Thank you all for your responses. It helped me gain a better understanding of the issues and to be aware of the consequences of each action.

    Kind regards

    Alay.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 18 total)