September 8, 2019
1. Sense faculties are a key concept in Buddha Dhamma. In mundane usage, we are used to identifying sense faculties as eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and the body.
- However, in Buddha Dhamma, there are two different Pāli words depending on the usage of those sense faculties.
- The sense faculties of a normal human are “internal āyatana“. With those, an average person experiences the outside world AND forms attachments to them.
- Then those external rūpā become “external āyatana“ (for example, “my house”, “my friend”, etc); see, “Contact Between Āyatana Leads to Vipāka Viññāna.” Therefore, external āyatana are the external rūpā that one gets attached to.
2. An Arahant has removed all greed, anger, and ignorance from the mind. The sense faculties of an Arahant are indriya. With his sensory faculties, an Arahant experiences “external rūpā“ such as “a house”, “a person”, etc. without any attachment. That house may be an elegant house where he lived some time back. But now it is just a house. That person could have been a “close friend” at that time, but now just another human being. Of course, the Arahant will recognize the house to be the one he lived in as a child and that the person was his friend.
- In brief, a sense faculty is an indriya if there is no “attachment”. It becomes an internal āyatana if one is attracted to it or repulsed by it. In the same way, an external rūpa becomes an external āyatana if one becomes attached to it.
- The Pāli word for attachment is “tanhā“. It is critical to realize “attachment” can take place via greed, anger, or ignorance. Once “attached”, one just keeps thinking about it (that means generating sankhāra; see below). Also, see “Tanhā – How We Attach Via Greed, Hate, and Ignorance“.
How Do Indriya Become Internal Āyatana?
3. First, let us further clarify the difference between an internal āyatana and an indriya.
- We have six sense faculties, not just the five mentioned above. They are eyes (cakkhu), ears (sōta), nose (ghāna), tongue (jivhā), body (kāya), and the mind (manō).
- Our initial sense inputs (what we see, hear, etc) are due to kamma vipāka. At the moment we experience them, we are using our sense faculties as indriya. For example, when we see an attractive person while on the road, that is just “seeing the event” with the cakkhu indriya.
- However, based on those initial sense experience, we may INTENTIONALLY use those indriya to enjoy that sensory experience again and again. Then those indriya become āyatana. In the above example, if we get attached to that attractive person and keep looking at that person, then we are using our eyes as cakkāyatana (cakkhu āyatana rhymes as cakkāyatana.)
- Therefore, an initial sensory event is captured by an indriya. But just after receiving that sensory input, we tend to use that sense faculty as an internal āyatana. That happens if we get attached or form “tanhā“; see #2 above.
- There is no equivalent English word for āyatana, so we will keep using indriya and āyatana from now on.
4. Let us take the example of two people eating a delicious cake. One is an average human (X) and the other an Arahant. Here the sense faculty is taste (jivhā).
- Both will generate the same kind of jivhā viññāna when they first taste it. That is just the taste of the cake. If the sensory elements in the tongue and the brain are working normally, both will be likely to find that cake “tasty”. That “good taste” is a kamma vipāka. (By the way, there is an infinite number of kamma vipāka waiting to bear fruit, including such a “small vipāka” as tasting a piece of cake.)
- The difference becomes apparent just after tasting the cake. The Arahant would forget all about that taste, even though he/she would have felt the “good taste”. It was just a sensory experience and thus the Arahant was using that sense faculty as an indriya.
- On the other hand, X may “fall in love” with that tasty cake. She may ask for another serving. Now she is using that sense faculty as a āyatana. She will be accumulating NEW kamma with such actions.
How One Indriya Can Lead to Many Āyatana (Salāyatana)
5. In many cases, when we experience a sensory event due to one indriya, we may start using some or all of the indriya as āyatana. Then the set of indriya becomes salāyatana.
- In the above example of a tasty cake (which is a kamma vipāka for both), they both experience “a tasty cake”. While the Arahant will not have any more thoughts about that taste, the average human (X) may be just getting started. She may ask for another piece even if she is not hungry.
- Let us analyze the situation carefully. The Arahant may accept a second piece if he is hungry. That request was not made because of a greedy thought. Thus, the tongue (or more precisely the jivhā pasāda) has NOT become a āyatana.
- If X asks for another piece even if she is not hungry, that is definitely due to craving for that taste. Then her tongue has become a āyatana. If she is hungry, her request could be based on BOTH hunger and craving. So, now her tongue (more precisely jivhā pasāda) is still a āyatana, but the difference is not as clear cut.
6. Whether or not X’s jivhā pasāda rūpā (internal indriya for tasting) has truly become a āyatana or not may become more clear if she takes further action.
- She may smell it and say, “it smells good too”. She may keep saying how good the taste is, and ask for the recipe or inquire about where to buy one.
- Now many of her sense faculties have become āyatana. Ghana pasāda rūpā (for smelling) has now become ghānāyatana (ghāna + āyatana).
- She is thinking about how to go about tasting that cake again. Therefore, the mind (mana) has become manāyatana (mana + āyatana).
- If she starts writing down the recipe, her body (kāya) is helping out too, acting as a kāyāyatana (kāya + āyatana).
- Therefore, when more than one āyatana become engaged, the set of āyatana (called salāyatana), may come into play. But it all started with just one sensory input, in this case eating a piece of cake.
Indriya Become Āyatana With Sankhāra
7. The easiest way to figure out whether an indriya has become an āyatana or not is to check whether one has started generating CONSCIOUS thoughts about that sensory input or experience.
- Interest in a sensory input leads to attachment to it via greed, revulsion, or ignorance.
- For example, the smell of good perfume can lead to thinking about buying it. Seeing an enemy, one may generate angry thoughts. In some situations, one may get confused about what to do and make the wrong decisions.
- Such CONSCIOUS thoughts are vaci and kāya sankhāra.
- Vaci sankhāra are “talking to oneself” and possibly speaking too. First, greedy/angry/ignorant thoughts are generated and those may lead to speaking out (lying, gossiping, etc).
- Kāya sankhāra involve bodily actions, for example, hitting, stealing, killings, etc. Here one would be using more āyatana since one would need to look and hear in addition to moving body parts.
8. Most of the time we use our sense faculties as indriya: we see, hear, etc many things in a day but ignore most of them. But when we experience something we have a craving for, then we start using our sense faculties as āyatana.
- The akusala-mula Paticca Samuppāda cycle operates only when we use our sense faculties as āyatana.
- Those sankhāra do not arise in an Arahant. That is because such sankhāra arise due to avijjā, i.e., they arise via “avijjā paccayā sankhāra”.
- An Arahant ALWAYS uses his/her sense faculties as indriya. He/she will see, hear, etc just like an average human, but will not get “attached to” anything. Therefore, the akusala-mula Paticca Samuppāda cycle does not operate for an Arahant.
Abhisankhāra Are Stronger Versions of Sankhāra
9. Some of those “extra activities” that we do with āyatana could be abhisankhāra. Just eating a cake is not abhisankhāra; see, “Kāma Guna, Kāma, Kāma Rāga, Kāmaccanda”.
- The distinction between sankhāra and abhisankhāra is clear-cut when those conscious thoughts (and therefore speech and actions) become immoral.
- Generating thoughts of anger on a person is abhisankhāra. Then telling a lie about that person is also abhisankhāra. Both are vaci kamma done with vaci (abhi)sankhāra.
- Stealing something or hitting someone is a kāya kamma done with kāya (abhi)sankhāra.
- Therefore, obviously immoral thoughts, speech, and actions are based on abhisankhāra. They are apunnābhisankhāra (apunna + abhi + sankhāra) or immoral strong sankhāra.
10. We can get some insights by analyzing the case of a young person (Z) becoming an alcoholic due to association with bad friends. As a child, Z may see a bottle of alcohol and would not generate any second thoughts about it. It would just be a “seeing event’ and Z would be only using his eyes (or more precisely cakkhu pasāda rūpā) as cakkhu indriya.
- But Z had some bad friends and they persuaded him to start drinking. He has now become an alcoholic. If he sees a bottle of alcohol now, he would immediately think about having a drink. Of course, he would have a drink If he is at a party. If he is at home, and the bottle belongs to his father, he may steal a drink from it. If he is traveling by himself and sees a bar, he may go in and have a drink.
- It could get even worse. He may be drinking at a party and may get into an argument with someone. Suppose that leads to a fight and he kills that person. He may get the death sentence or at least go to jail for a long time. But a much worse outcome awaits him at his death. He would be born in an apāya.
- I hope you can see that vaci and kāya sankhāra are behind all those. In fact, they are strong sankhāra. They are thus abhisankhāra. If he kills someone, that is due to an apunnābhisankhāra. That would qualify him to be born in an apāya.
11. There are also punnābhisankhāra (punna + abhi + sankhāra) or moral strong sankhāra.
- For example, feeding a hungry person or giving to charity are kāya kamma done with strong kāya sankhāra. They are both punnābhisankhāra.
- Such strong punna kamma done with punnābhisankhāra lead to good rebirths (in human and higher realms).
How Do External Rupā Become External Āyatana?
12. The moment an indriya becomes an internal āyatana, the corresponding external rūpā becomes an external āyatana.
- Let us consider the following example. You are walking down a street and see a person coming toward you at a distance. Without recognizing who it is, your eyes are working only as indriya. But as the person gets closer, you recognize him as one of your friends. At that moment, your cakkhu indriya has become a cakkhayatana. At the same time, that external rūpā of a “person” has now become a “friend”.
- To take that one step further, suppose after some time you get into an argument with that friend and it escalates to the point that he has become an enemy. Now if you see him on the road, you will recognize him as an enemy. At that moment of seeing him, your cakkhu indriya will again become an internal āyatana, and his body that you see will become an external āyatana.
- However, those two external āyatana are very different. In one case you saw a friend and in the other an enemy, even though that external rūpā (body of that other person) was the same.
13. We can find many examples in our daily lives to see how an indriya becomes a āyatana. In another example, suppose you park the car on the side of the road and go to a restaurant to eat. When you come back, you see that someone has bumped his car into it and there is a scratch on it. You, of course, get upset.
- Suppose after a while you sell that car. Then a few days later, you see that it has been totally destroyed in an accident. But now you are not upset about the same car getting destroyed. When you see that badly-damaged car, your cakkhu indriya does not become an internal āyatana. And that external rūpa (the car) does not become an external āyatana.
- The only difference was that you had given up the attachment to that car the moment you sold it. It is no longer “your car”. It became just another car, the moment you gave up the “ownership” of the car.
How to Stop Indriya Becoming Āyatana?
14. That last example illustrates how one ends suffering at the Arahanthood. When on longer attaches to ANYTHING in this world, one’s mind will not be perturbed by anything. That includes knowing that one day one’s own body will die.
- However, that state of mind of Arahanthood cannot even be comprehended by an average human. It is a long process from being an average human to becoming an Arahant.
- We must follow the path step-by-step. Those attachments to “worldly things” CANNOT be forcefully removed from one’s mind. The first step is to comprehend the unfruitfulness AND danger of doing IMMORAL things in order to get sensory enjoyment. See, “Is It Necessary for a Buddhist to Eliminate Sensual Desires?“.
- However, it is good to get an overview of the “big picture” or the fundamentals of Buddha Dhamma at the beginning. That is necessary to discard the wrong views about this world including kamma and kamma vipāka, and the validity of the rebirth process. With wrong views about such fundamental concepts, one cannot even start on the Noble Eightfold Path.
- That is why this series on “Origins of Life” is so important. One must evaluate all existing views (which we summarized in the early posts in this series). The Buddhist view is more complex and it will take several more posts to complete.