Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
On June 16, 2024 at 10:47 am (comment #50277) Pathfinder asked: “If that is the case, can you explain how Buddha knew that Santati will attain arahantship and parinibbana that very day?”
- That does not mean EVERYTHING is deterministic.
- I explained that in the post “Pāramitā – How a Puthujjana Becomes a Buddha.”
- Even a Buddha first gets “aniyata vivarana” or “not fully confirmed.” As a Bodhisatta continues to fulfill more paramita, a later Buddha would see that the Bodhisatta is “definitely going to attain the Buddhahood.” That is when a Bodhisatta gets “niyata vivarana” or “definite confirmation.” See #2 of the post.
- Some “predictions” may not be realized if prevailing conditions change. See #4 through #6 in the same post.
I am sorry I did not get to address some of the issues brought up.
- I think this discussion is very fruitful. It revealed some issues I need to address in upcoming posts. Thanks to Pathfinder for starting the discussion and all for the active discussion.
The following post is important: “Anatta – the Opposite of Which Atta?“
- I will write about other issues later when I have more time—I’m still traveling.
4 users thanked author for this post.
OK. I will try to do that after my travels.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Some of the points made above are per “mundane logic” and do not consider the “wider worldview” of the Buddha. Our conclusions must apply to all living beings.
- First, let us address the issue: “Does any living being have free will”?
- The answer is no. See “Distorted Saññā Arises in Every Adult but Not in a Newborn” (especially #6). Thus, not even all humans have free will. P.S. However, Most humans above age seven (with a fully working brain) have free will.
- In addition, animals and other beings in the apayas do not have free will.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Good comments!
1. I think it was Nagarjuna or Buddhaghosa who tried to explain the basic theme of Buddha’s teachings with “there is no doer, it’s all just causes and effects.”
- That is not the way to correctly interpret the teachings.
2. If you apply Paticca Samuppada without grasping how the mind works differently in different realms, you can come to that WRONG conclusion.
- That saying applies to animals and beings in the other three apayas. They don’t have free will.
3. The reason for humans to have free will is mainly two-fold:
- As explained in Abhidhamma, the most potent javana arises when a good deed is done with an understanding of the anicca nature, i.e., when one does it with “sōmanassa sahagata ñāna sampayutta citta” (or “thoughts with joyful mind based on wisdom”) Suich cittas (thoughts) do not arise in those beings in apayas but arise in humans. See “Feelings: Sukha, Dukha, Somanassa, and Domanassa.” (especially #10)
- Humans also have fully developed brains. The brain “slows down” our response to external sensory inputs because it takes time for the brain to process sensory information. See “Triune Brain: How the Mind Rewires the Brain via Meditation/Habits.”
As I mentioned above, this topic is critically important. The above two points need to be discussed in detail, but those two posts should be helpful. Keep asking questions based on those two posts.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Yes. This is a subtle and vital issue. Taryal has a general sense of it.
- Even though there is no “me” in the ultimate reality, everyone below the Arahant stage has a “sense of me” because they do not comprehend the true nature of reality.
- That ignorance is avijja.
- That avijja manifests when one attaches (automatically) to certain types of sensory inputs based on the types of gati they have at that time. One’s gati can change based on one’s associations (mostly family and friends). The “Gati Sutta (AN 9.68)” describes the five major gati that lead to rebirths. There can be innumerable gati within those five types.
- The first three gati are removed (and one becomes free of rebirths in the apayas) at the Sotapanna stage when one starts comprehending Buddha’s worldview, i.e., when critical wrong views (sakkaya ditthi) are removed. The other two are removed at the Anagami and Arahant stages. That requires removing “distorted sanna“
- I am traveling for several days and may not be able to respond fully. But I will try to find time to respond further when I have more time. In the meantime, please ask more questions so I can answer them all.
The word “upadhi” has a deeper meaning. See the two top search results below:
1 user thanked author for this post.
The following is a documentary on the high-precision Barbar caves in India, an engineering marvel. How was such precision attained thousands of years ago?
2 users thanked author for this post.
Thank you, Jittananto.
- Yes. We need to handle each case differently, depending on the situation.
- The following post is relevant: “Right Speech – How to Avoid Accumulating Kamma.”
2 users thanked author for this post.
I think the main points are the following:
1. We must do all we can to inform others of Buddha’s teachings. It is out of our hands how many would be interested.
2. However, the Buddha discouraged anyone from forcefully teaching Dhamma to others or engaging in “debates” that may escalate and become unproductive.
Regarding who is qualified to teach:
1. The “Ministry of the Buddha” or the “Buddha Sāsana” with the unique message of the Buddha will last only as long as there are Noble Persons (those who have attained magga phala, i.e., Sotapanna through Arahant) stages.
– They have the special name “kalyāṇa mittā” of a “Noble friend.”2. Only a Buddha or a true disciple of the Buddha (who has grasped the teachings of the Buddha) can explain those teachings.
– Once there is no longer any such kalyāṇa mittā on the Earth, Buddha Sāsana will disappear. Full copies of the Tipitaka may be there, but there will be no one to explain their contents. This is also why “word-by-word” translations are useless: “Elephant in the Room 1 – Direct Translation of the Tipiṭaka“
– Then, the world will have to wait for the next Buddha, Buddha Maitreya, to be born to attain magga phala (Nibbana.) That is supposed to happen in a billion years or so.
– The current Buddha Sāsana of Buddha Gotama is expected to disappear within the next 2000 years.3. That is why the Buddha told Ven. Ananda (in the Upaḍḍha Sutta (SN 45.2)) that the continuation of his Buddha Sāsana depends TOTALLY on kalyāṇa mittā.
Good analysis. Thank you!
1 user thanked author for this post.
Yes. In many instances, Pali tends to combine many words.
- “Sokaparidevadukkhadomanassupāyāsā” = soka, parideva, dukkha, domanassa, upāyāsa.
- Those are related words indicating sorrow/pain associated with various situations.
The main ideas are associated with death (marana), which is inevitable for each birth (jati). In Paticca Samuppada: “bhava paccayā jāti, jāti paccayā jarā, marana, soka-paridēva-dukkha-dōmanassupāyasā sambhavan’ti”
- Each birth leads to jarā (old age and decay) and marana (death). Of course, one is not aware of one’s death. But we all have suffered due to the death of a close relative, in particular, if it is a parent, spouse, or child.
- When one first hears about such a death, one becomes sad (soka). Then, whoever is present there starts talking about their relationship, good times, or special events with the deceased, and the sadness grows to parideva. If intense feelings arise, one can feel it in the body (dukkha), and the sad state of mind (domanassa) can last for days. The last one, upāyasa, is the most intense state; for example, when the deceased is taken to be buried or cremated, a sense of despair can come over, and some start crying and wailing, and some even faint.
1 user thanked author for this post.
I think what Christian is trying to say is the following:
- In Buddha Dhamma, there are two main types of meditation: Samatha (calming the mind by staying away from immoral deeds and focusing on living a moral life) and Vipassana (contemplate Dhamma concepts like Tilakkhana and Paticca Samuppada and how they help explain the Four Noble Truths).
- What types of “meditation” are you doing? For example, you mentioned “NSDR (Non-Sleep Deep Rest) meditation.” What is that?
- In the Western world, “meditation” usually means “breath meditation.” That is not a Buddhist meditation. See “Vipassanā – Buddhist Meditation.”
