Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Those five realms are in “rupa loka.” I just revised #8 to say that specifically:
“8. Anāgāmis who have “burned” kāma rāga saṁyojana and thus permanently severed their connection to kāma loka will be reborn in five realms in rupa loka RESERVED for them: Aviha, Atappa, Sudassa, Sudassi, and Akanittakha. These realms are called “Suddhāvāsa” or “pure abodes.” See a description in the “Saṅgīti Sutta (DN 33)” starting with “Pañca suddhāvāsā—avihā, atappā, sudassā, sudassī, akaniṭṭhā.”
1 user thanked author for this post.
Yes. However, Ven. Sariputta was only next to the Buddha in wisdom (paññā.)
- He conducted the first “Dhamma Sangāyanā” (Recital of the Teachings) by himself.
- When Nigaṇṭhassa Nāṭaputta (the leader of the Jains) died, his followers started quarreling about who should take over the leadership. Ven. Sariputta told a gathering of bhikkhus that they would not need a leader after the Parinibbana of the Buddha and he was going to summarize the teachings of the Buddha.
- That was the first recital of the Buddha’s teachings in one sitting!
- The background and the summarized teachings are in the “Saṅgīti Sutta (DN 33).”
2 users thanked author for this post.
Yes. Thank you!
1 user thanked author for this post.
Yes. Even Ven. Sariputta did not have that capability. Another sutta (I forget the name) describes how Ven. Sariputta was giving instructions to a bhikkhu, and the Buddha told Ven. Sarputta that the bhikkhu had attained Arahanthood.
Each Arahant is different and may have varying capabilities. Only a Buddha has all possible capabilities.
- In another sutta, the Buddha explained to Ven. Sariputta that in a congregation of 500 bhikkhus, all were Arahants but had varying attainments: “Of these five hundred monks, sixty have the three knowledges (tevijjā), sixty have abhiññā powers, sixty are freed both ways (ubhatobhāgavimutta), and the rest are freed by wisdom (paññāvimutta).”
- See “Pavāraṇā Sutta (SN 8.7).”
1 user thanked author for this post.
“However Is there a broad or a standard framework prescribed by the Vaijja (the Great Doctor) for those who are willing to learn and work on it? Not just cigarette but breaking free of Sensual Pleasures as such?”
That is what I described in the comment above.
- The only way to get rid of “bad practices” (not only smoking but other cravings also) is to see their drawbacks.
- It helps a lot to understand that all those cravings are rooted in “distorted saññā” i.e., those cravings are “mind-made.”
- It is necessary to understand the ideas described in “Fooled by Distorted Saññā (Sañjānāti) – Origin of Attachment (Taṇhā)” and “Mūlapariyāya Sutta – The Root of All Things“ and other posts.
- I don’t seem to be making that point clear. I am not sure what it would take to get this idea across. There are no other “easy ways out.”
1 user thanked author for this post.
Things to think about:
1. Do all beings have DNA? Brahmas in 20 realms (and most likely Devas in 6 realms) don’t have DNA. Even human or animal gandhabbas don’t have DNA. So, trying to sort out things by looking at DNA is not a good idea.
2. All lifeforms ALWAYS have a manomaya kaya. That manomaya kaya defines/determines not only the realm of existence but even minor variations within a given realm. For example, no two humans are the same.
3. The total number of “beings” in our cakkavāla centered around the Earth remains constant, except when Arahants attain Parinibbana at their death and leave this world.
4. By the time this cakkavāla is destroyed, all beings in the realms below the pabhassara Brahma realms migrate to that pabhassara Brahma realm. But the realms above that are not destroyed.
5. When the Earth is re-formed, most of those Brahmas in the pabhassara realm migrate back to Earth. Then their “old gati” gradually come back and over billions of years they are reborn in various realms. Of course, those gati keep changing too. Nothing is fixed.
6. Births are always according to gati, not according to DNA.
- You wrote: “There are similarities between the birds and extinct flying dinosaurs.”
- Birds and dinosaurs are two different species. Their manomaya kaya (or gandhabba kaya) are different. Birds did not “evolve” from dinosaurs. The fact that dinosaurs went extinct possibly due to a meteor impact which made conditions unsuitable for their survival. As the Earth recovered, conditions became suitable for “bird gandhabbas” to be born with physical bodies. Even now, there could be some “dinosaur gandhabbas.” But conditions are not suitable for them to thrive.
- In the same way, humans and apes have different gati. Darwin’s “evolution theory” is already showing signs of weakness. Evidence is emerging that humans have lived much earlier than believed at the time of Darwin.
I suggest re-reading the post “Buddhism and Evolution – Aggañña Sutta (DN 27)” with those facts in mind.
2 users thanked author for this post.
Yes. Your craving for smoking can easily be broken since it is not an addiction yet.
Regarding your statement, “The Pleasure vanishes away. Of little taste and utility- Alpa Swada -Anityata (Dhammapada 186).”
- Alpa Swada in Pāli is “appassada” or “appa” “assāda” where “appa” means “little” and “assāda” is (mind-made) pleasures.”
- That verse is discussed in “Dhammapada Verses 186 and 187.”
In the “Dutiyayodhājīva Sutta (AN 5.76)” the Buddha says: “‘appassādā, āvuso, kāmā vuttā bhagavatā bahudukkhā bahupāyāsā, ādīnavo ettha bhiyyo” OR “‘Reverend, the Buddha says that sensual pleasures give little gratification and much suffering and distress, and they are all the more full of drawbacks.”
- While some people crave smoking, most people do not like the smell. Thus, it is mind-made, i.e., a basic example of “distorted saññā.”
- See “Fooled by Distorted Saññā (Sañjānāti) – Origin of Attachment (Taṇhā)” and “Mūlapariyāya Sutta – The Root of All Things“
- You can contemplate the ādinava (health issues) of smoking and give it up.
- That is an easy thing to give up compared to other cravings.
“Speaking with doubt” is not that appropriate.
- “mosavajjañca kathaṅkathā” is better expressed by “resort to lies and gossip with ignorance.”
- We must realize that dictionaries were written by (well-educated) puthujjana like Rhys Davids, who were “scholars” but had no magga phala.
P.S. “Pāli Dictionaries – Are They Reliable?“
2 users thanked author for this post.
“Is it correct that one writes duk(k)ha vedanā with two k when it relates to physical pain? My understanding is that physical suffering is dukha and the suffering from which we can free ourselves with Buddha Dhamma is written dukkha.”
- Yes. That is correct.
Dukha and sukha vedana are felt by the physical body (“sārīra.”) Dukha vedana is usually written as dukkha vedana, per your explanation.
- adukkhamasukha vedanā comes from “adukkha asukha” (rhymes like “adukkhamasukha”) or “not painful or pleasant.”
- All other vedana (somanassa and domanassa) are mind-made. Pleasant ones are somanassa, and unpleasant ones are domanassa.
- For example, the sight of an attractive person provides only an adukkhamasukha vedanā. However, due to “distorted sanna,” the mind generates a somanassa vedana. For example, animals don’t see any beauty in a woman. They become joyful when they see whoever takes care of them.
- The same holds for sounds, tastes, smells, etc. As we discussed, we don’t like the taste or smell of rotten meat, but pigs like them.
- However, physical pain is common to all. It is real and not “mind-made.” Of course, on top of that, we may generate additional domanassa vedana!
1 user thanked author for this post.
Thank you for providing the two essential references on Ven. Sariputta attaining Arahanthood.
- I had not thought about this before, but it appears that Ven. Sariputta was an ubhtovimutta Arahant. The translations seem to be correct.
- Note that in the first sutta that Gad cited (Anupada Sutta), it was the Buddha who described how Ven. Sariputta attained Arahanthood and simultaneously got to nirodha samapatti.
- So, Ven. Sariputta attained the ubhtovimutta Arahanthood while listening to the discourse delivered to the wanderer Dīghanakha, per the second sutta, Dīghanakha Sutta. This sutta only says Ven. Sariputta attained Arahanthood, but does not provide details. The details are in the first sutta.
Note that Ven. Culapanthaka also attained ubhtovimutta Arahanthood while contemplating Buddha’s instructions. The whole sequence can happen very quickly. That is why the Buddha stated that the subject of jhana is incomprehensible (acinteyya) for anyone other than a Buddha.
- See “Acinteyya Sutta (AN 4.77).” Four things are fully comprehensible only to a Buddha: “knowledge base of a Buddha and the subjects of jhāna, kamma vipāka, and the world (universe).”
1 user thanked author for this post.
1. “Nirodha samapatti” is not possible for all who has cultivated the 4 jhānas and the 4 arupavacara samapatti. Just because one has cultivated the 4 jhānas and the 4 arupavacara samapatti that does not mean they can get into “nirodha samapatti.“
- “Nirodha samapatti” means to experience the “full Nibbana” (for up to seven days) before the death of the physical body.
- That is the main point.
2. Anariya yogis can cultivate the 4 jhānas and the 4 arupavacara samapatti. But they cannot get to “nirodha samapatti.“
3. “Nirodha samapatti” is possible only for “cetovimutti Arahants.“
- A “cetovimutti Arahant” is an Arahant who has cultivated the 4 jhānas and the 4 arupavacara samapatti.
5. A “pannavimutti Arahant” is an Arahant who has NOT cultivated ALL of the 4 jhānas and the 4 arupavacara samapatti. They may not have cultivated even a single jhana.
- They also cannot get to “nirodha samapatti.“
Please read the post “Samādhi, Jhāna, and Sammā Samādhi” (especially #10) carefully to understand the above.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Regarding rrkk01’s question above:
It is correct that gandhabba is also made of matter. In fact, a gandhabba is made of the smallest elements of matter called “suddhatthaka.”
- Contrary to mundane thinking, sometimes “lighter things” are more stable than heavy things. For example, anything dense, like rocks and even metal, can be burned at high enough temperatures. However, even at such high temperatures, air molecules are not burned.
- In another example, dense things like metal sheets can be cut by saws or laser light. However, air molecules cannot be cut like that.
A gandhabba can be created ONLY by kammic energy and destroyed ONLY by the mechanisms I mentioned earlier.
- The essence of a gandhabba is the hadaya vatthu (seat of the mind) and five pasada rupa. Those are very special entities because it is not that bit of matter, but they also have the following unique capabilities:
- A hadaya vatthu is the ONLY entity in this world that can generate thoughts (citta). Five pasada rupa are the only things in this world that can detect sights, sounds, tastes, smells, and touch sensations.
- Our eyes, ears, etc., only bring signals from the external world into the physical body, and the brain only processes such information. Then, those signals are transmitted by the brain to the gandhabba. Hadaya vatthu of the gandhabba receives those signals via the five pasada rupa and, in turn, generates citta (thoughts) in response. See “Brain – Interface between Mind and Body“
P.S. All existences (lives) start with a manomaya kaya (“mind-made body”) with a hadaya vatthu and up to five pasada rupa.
- There is no “gap”, i.e, a lifestream ALWAYS has a manomaya kaya. For example, if a human existence ends with the death of a human gandhabba, and if the next existence is in the animal realm, then an animal gandhabba is born at the moment that human gandhabba dies.
- The manomaya kaya is called a gandhabba only in the human and animal realms. That is because only in those two realms that dense physical bodies arise subsequently based on that gandhabba.
- In the Deva realms, the gandhabba kaya arises together with the physical body. Devas have less dense physical bodies compared to humans. They also have five pasada rupas like humans.
- The rupa loka Brahmas have a hadaya vatthu and two pasada rupa. Thus the structure is similar to that of a human gandhabba, but only with two pasada rupa. They are not called gandhabbas because they don’t make subsequent physical bodies based on that manomaya kaya.
- The arupa loka Brahmas have a hadaya vatthu but no pasada rupa. Thus, it has only the mind.
- The hadaya vatthu is also present in the asanna realm. But it is entirely trapped in a physical body with no “doors” to the external world, i.e., no eyes, ears, mouth, tongue, or nervous system to sense the touch. Also, there is no brain to bring in memories.
Make sure to understand this basic picture. Keep asking questions if anything is unclear.
1 user thanked author for this post.
I am not certain whether it is the following post that Lang had in mind, but it discusses that issue about the asañña realm.
A traumatic event probably strongly affects the gandhabba‘s mental state. That may manifest in the new human body.
- Some people who had died by drowning in their previous lives get terrified when seeing a large body of water and are scared of swimming.
- Some chronic headaches have been cured by “life regression therapy.” Google that and see.
3 users thanked author for this post.
