Reply To: What stays after death?

…can call it Deva X), expired the life there, and just grasped a human existence (human bhava). 2. When that Deva X disappeared from the Brahma realm, a human gandhabba

Reply To: Gandhabba Timespan

Lang asked: “I’m assuming that a gandhabba can stay in the gandhabba form for thousands of year straight, without birth (jati) as a human with a physical body.” – Yes….

Reply To: Hadaya vatthu in asanna realm

“This blood-dependency is in contradiction to the Gandhabba idea, I think. I think it is due to commentary?” Gandhabba (at the moment of patisandhi) is just a few suddhatthaka. How…

Reply To: Tirokudda Sutta

Thank you, Lal. A good and clear post. One follow-up question: A bhava in hell does not start with Gandhabba, but always with a birth moment in a hell body?…

Reply To: Utuja kaya of Gandhabba

If the Gandhabba is not embodied, there are no “bodily” sensations? I mean, there are no sensations generated through utuja kaya and impinging on “kaya pasada rupa”? Or, alternatively, if…

Reply To: Evolution and Gandhabba

I watched the video and the evidence is compelling. Daniel wrote: “Since we know from the Buddha’s Agañña Sutta, that the human gandhabba (or human bhava) is existing for much…

Reply To: Split Reincarnation

…The Gandhabba of the baby left already, but another Gandhabba of a man who died in a nearby village was advised to “seek shelter” (by another spirit) in the dying…

Reply To: Split Reincarnation

…at a given time. 2. It is possible for a gandhabba to come out of a womb, and for another gandhabba to take possession of that zygote in the womb….

Reply To: Split Reincarnation

…was 29 years old. As such, the lifetimes of Cary and Parkhurst overlapped by 29 years. – That is not possible. How can the same gandhabba live in two different…