Lal

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,831 through 1,845 (of 4,454 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Regarding sotapanna Anugami with Jhāna #42176
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Theruwan Saranayi!

    1. Yes. The duration of the jhana does not matter. As long as one has attained a jhana citta vithi, one has transcended the “kama loka.” Thus the yogi will be born in a Brahma realm. However, in the case of an anariya jhana, that is only temporary, meaning the yogi will return to kama loka at the end of that Brahma birth. But if one has ALSO attained at least the Sotapanna Anugami stage, that yogi will not return to kama loka.

    2. The duration of the time does not matter, as explained above. P.S. You asked, “how can one would be in jhana(not samapatti) while walking.” One can be in a jhana with even iddhi powers while engaging in physical activities. It is only in a jhana samapatti that one is unaware of the surroundings; see the post referred to at the end. Note that there is an account in the Tipitaka where Culapanathaka Thero made 1000 copies of himself and worked with them at his temple; see “Are There Procedures for Attaining Magga Phala, Jhāna and Abhiññā?“

    3. This is where many people come to the wrong conclusions. Jhanic experience is discussed in detail by the Buddha in “Jhānic Experience in Detail – Sāmañ­ña­phala Sutta (DN 2).”

    4. Details on vitakka/vicara and savitakka./savicara at “Vitakka, Vicāra, Savitakka, Savicāra, and Avitakka, Avicāra.”

     

    I just revised the post “Citta Vīthi – Processing of Sense Inputs,” where further details can be found.

    Lal
    Keymaster

    Thank you!

    I revised that sentence as:

    • Thus we can see that kāma assāda, saṅkappa rāga, and vaci saṅkhāra mean the same thing. Of course, vaci saṅkhāra may also lead to kāya saṅkhāra.

    I have also made some other revisions too.

    in reply to: Most Important Basics #42116
    Lal
    Keymaster

    TGS wrote: “Without going into further details, a Sotapanna would know yoniso manasikara. “

    • Yes. This is the same as what I wrote in #2 in my comment above: “That means understanding Paticca Samuppada (PS), which explains how one’s actions/mindset leads to different rebirths.” That is why yoniso manasikara is one of the four conditions for attaining the Sotapanna stage.
    • If one can understand the implications, one can start seeing why it is unfruitful/dangerous to seek sensual pleasures. The first step there is to see the dangers of engaging in immoral deeds seeking sensual pleasures, i.e.,  generating apunna abhisankhara (“avijja paccaya sankhara.“) That is when one starts seeing the anicca nature (and that it leads to dukkha and anatta.)

    Dipobhasaddhamma: You seem to be on the Noble Path based on what you wrote. Of course, no one can vouch for anyone else’s attainments. 

    • Once one gets to the Anagami stage, there will be no doubts because no lustful thoughts can arise regardless of how strong a sensory input (arammana) is.

     

    in reply to: Most Important Basics #42112
    Lal
    Keymaster

    It is a good question. 

    The answer depends on the level of understanding of the person. One way to look at it is as follows.

    1. There are two paths: mundane and lokuttara (Noble).

    • One must complete the mundane eightfold path first. That means getting rid of the ten wrong views (miccha ditthi.) As long as one does not believe in kamma and their vipaka, the validity of the rebirth process, that there are living beings in other realms, etc., one does not have the necessary background to comprehend the Four Noble Truths/Paticca Samuppada/Tilakkhana.
    • I keep wondering whether I need to add more posts on completing the mundane path. Relevant posts at “Moral Living and Fundamentals” and “Living Dhamma.”
    • P.S. The importance of getting rid of miccha ditthi is discussed in “Micchā Diṭṭhi, Gandhabba, and Sōtapanna Stage.”

    2. Once one gets rid of those wrong views, the next step is to be exposed to the correct explanations of our Noble Truths/Paticca Samuppada/Tilakkhana.

    • The Noble Truths are about the suffering in the rebirth process, how that suffering arises due to attachment to worldly things (which people perceive as pleasures), and how to overcome that attachment by seeing the dangers of remaining in the rebirth process. 
    • That means understanding Paticca Samuppada (PS), which explains how one’s actions/mindset leads to different rebirths. In particular, understanding what types of actions (via apunna abhisankhara) lead to births in the apayas.
    • Then, simultaneously, one would realize the anicca, dukkha, and anatta nature of this world of 31 realms.

    So, yes, a Sotapanna Anugami starts on the Noble Path by getting a glimpse of that “deeper vision.” Once getting to that point, there is no turning back because the more one contemplates the nature of this world, the more one becomes convinced about the futility AND danger of remaining in the rebirth process.

    That is one way to look at it. “Paṭicca Samuppāda, Tilakkhana, Four Noble Truths.”

    Of course, there are always more details. We can discuss any suggestions. 

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    in reply to: Is this a misunderstanding? #42040
    Lal
    Keymaster

    1. As I have explained in many posts, Four Noble Truths is the same as Paticca Samuppada. Those encompass Tilakkhana (anicca, dukkha, anatta.) None of those is known in the absence of a Buddha.

    2. It is a waste of time to read any document that translates anicca as impermanence and anatta as no-self.

    3. If a Tipitaka reference can be provided for the following statement, we can discuss that: “The characteristics of anicca and dukkha are known whether Buddhas arise or not.” There is no such reference!

    • Note the dukkha in the above statement cannot be taken as merely “suffering” either. Suffering is dukha. Since suffering is known to even animals, a Buddha is not needed to show us that “suffering exists.”
    • On the other hand, dukkha is “dukha + khaya.”  Without a Buddha, we will not know how to overcome that suffering, i.e., the Dukkha Sacca.

     

     

    in reply to: Pragnā Sāsana & Karunā Sāsana #42038
    Lal
    Keymaster

    The following is the latest in that series, which was just posted to Youtube. Thanks to Janith Fernando for sending it to me.

    • Again, if you find anything that needs clarification, please comment and refer to the time in the video. I have not watched either of the videos due to the lack of time. It will be easy to check since both Sinhala, and English versions are there. Thank you, Janith! Much merit for your efforts!

    in reply to: Dutiyaovādasutta (SN 16.7) #42018
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Sometimes “santi” is used to express “there are.”

    See, for example, “Suddhika Sutta (SN 31.1)“

    TGS: When you provide a link, you should select “new window” in the “target box” in the “insert link” popup. That will open the page in a new tab. I have done that to your link, and now the sutta opens in a new tab in your comment.

    • For those who are not sure how to provide a link, click on the “chain link” symbol. When you hover over each formatting symbol, it tells you what it does. For example, “B” is for “bold.”
    • One must select the text to be bolded, italicized, etc. When providing a link, select the title of the link and then click the link symbol in the formatting panel.
    in reply to: Dovacassatāsutta AN 6.115 #42002
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Select the sentence that you want to be “bold” or “italics,” and then press the “b” or “i” on the format bar. That will solve the formatting issue. I corrected the first “bolded ” sentence in your comment.

    Yes. I will try to address those when I have time. A lot can be written on various issues/concepts, but it is a matter of having enough time.

    in reply to: Paccaya Sutta (SN12.27) #41987
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Yes. A sekkha is a Noble Person at or above the Sotapanna Anugami stage, training to be an Arahant (Asekha). 

    Two suttas explain a sekha:

    “Sekkha Sutta (SN 45.13)” and “Sekkha Sutta (AN 3.85).”

    The English translations can be improved. For example, the following verse in the second sutta “Adhisīlampi sikkhati, adhicittampi sikkhati, adhipaññampi sikkhati. Sikkhatīti kho, bhikkhu, tasmā sekhoti vuccatīti” can be a bit better translated as:

    “They train with Ariyakanta sila (Adhisīla,) they cultivate defilement-free thoughts (dhicitta) with the comprehension of Tilakkhana (adhipañña.) That’s why they are called a ‘trainee’.”

    See #4 of “Sotapatti Aṅga – The Four Qualities of a Sotāpanna” for a description of “ariyakanta sila.”

     

    Lal
    Keymaster

    I am compiling evidence (as they come in) for the existence of ancient, highly spiritual, and technologically advanced civilizations. 

    The reason is that it is inevitable that they existed, according to the Tipitaka. The “Mahāpadāna Sutta (DN 14)” provides a detailed description of the existence of three Buddhas before Buddha Gotama in this maha kappa (meaning this Earth) that was formed about 4.5 billion years ago.

    • P.S. The current eon (maha kappa) is known as a “bhaddakappa” (or a fortunate eon) because it will have five Buddhas born before its end. There can be many maha kappas without a single Buddha. As the above sutta states, there were 30 maha kappas before the current one without a single Buddha. There were two Buddhas in the 31 eons before the current one.

    Civilizations can end with mass extinctions due to several possible cataclysmic events, such as a comet impact or an enormous earthquake.

    • The acquired knowledge and technology can be completely wiped out due to such an event. 
    • It is not easy to find or verify the existence of such ancient civilizations because of the unimaginable period of even several million years, let alone over four billion years.
    • However, there is already enough evidence to see that the currently accepted timeline of human evolution is wrong, which says agriculture was invented only 12,000 years ago: “The Development of Agriculture.”
    • That is incorrect since it has now been verified (with carbon dating) that advanced structures were built before that timeline; for example, “Gobekli Tepe: Facts, Discovery, and Location.” The videos posted in my earlier posts above provide more information.
    • More evidence will hopefully emerge. The main problem is that metals, when submerged in the Earth, decay and do not last even a million years. So, if a human civilization built rockets many millions ago, there will be no trace of that left. But the evidence for advanced ancient civilizations may appear unexpectedly as our technologies improve and may lead to evidence from yet unimagined ways.  
    1 user thanked author for this post.
    in reply to: Pragnā Sāsana & Karunā Sāsana #41955
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Yes. This is a better format for the translation of Waharaka Thero’s discourses.

    I have not listened to/read it, so I cannot vouch for its accuracy. But if anyone has questions about a possible error with the translation, please comment, referring to the video’s exact time(s).

    Thank you, Sacket!

     

    in reply to: rupakkhandha vs saññākhandha #41946
    Lal
    Keymaster

    As I said, I cannot explain these things without you having a basic understanding. It is just a waste of time for both of us.

    This is a common problem. People want to get into complex things like “where are memories stored?”, “how do gandhabbas communicate?” etc., without understanding saññā, the difference between rupa and rupakkhandha, etc.

    • Spend the time and understand the basics. That will be a good investment.
    • I will be happy to discuss any issues with the posts that I have suggested.
    in reply to: rupakkhandha vs saññākhandha #41943
    Lal
    Keymaster

    “I will read and try to ask question from your posts then.”

     

    OK. That is fine. There is no point in discussing gandhabba if you cannot understand saññā, the difference between rupa and rupakkhandha, etc.

    in reply to: rupakkhandha vs saññākhandha #41941
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Hello Sachin,

    You should first understand what saññā is. Please read the post:

    “Saññā – What It Really Means“

    Also, read the first two posts in the section, because that helps solidify the concept of saññā with examples:

    “Essential Abhidhamma – The Basics“

    Question by LDF: “I think intuition is related to saññā, in some way, is that correct?”

    Intuition on a given object is based on first recognizing (saññā) the object and any other relevant objects.

    • For example, your intuition of not to touch a red-hot metal comes because you recognize that metal is heated and can burn.
    Lal
    Keymaster

    Hello Tobi,

    Consciousness (vinnana) is many types. But they can be divided into TWO main types.

    1. Awareness (Consciousness)

    You become aware of a rupa (say, a tree) when you look at it. That is cakkhu vinnana (eye consciousness). When you become aware of a sound, that is sota vinnana (ear consciousness), etc. The sixth is mano vinnana, where you become aware of a past event (memory). That last happens via “manañca paṭicca dhammē ca uppajjāti manō viññāṇaṃ.” The first one happens via“cakkhuñca paṭicca rupē ca uppajjāti cakkhu viññāṇaṃ.”

    Those are vipaka vinnana (of six types.) We cannot avoid them while we live.

    2. Creating a Mind (rebirth consciousness or patisandhi vinnana) for a new existence (in the rebirth process)

    This happens at the end of current existence (say, Deva) and grasping a new existence (say, human).

    This happens via “upadana paccaya bhava” and “bhava paccaya jati” steps in Uppatti Paticca Samuppada. This also involves a dhammā. 

    • However, this dhammā differs from dhammā in recalling a memory in #1 above. This dhammā is a STRONG kamma bija that can lead to rebirth.
    • These are kamma vinnana.

    EXCEPTION: There are not so strong dhammā that can bring vipaka vinnana during life. These are more than memories. Memories don’t have kammic energy. These also belong to #1 above.

    See “Viññāṇa – Consciousness Together With Future Expectations.” see #3.

Viewing 15 posts - 1,831 through 1,845 (of 4,454 total)