Reply To: Discourse 4 – Sakkaya Ditthi – What is “a Person”?

#14422
y not
Participant

Embodied:

Travelled a road, yes, and for much too long; for since that Road is without beginning, it can only be toooooo long.

As to the knowledge (not so much the use) of Pali, I used to think much as you do,but I have come to see its value. Many words have multiple meanings (to say nothing of those translated wrongly) and we, or I for one, would not have found those out by ourselves, or only partly so, but then with great difficulty, if at all.

I see what you mean and I agree that if the knowledge of Pali were a prerequisite, then all those on the Way would come from the Indian sub-continent – and the Path cannot have such race and geographical restrictions. Moreover, he who has made himself ready to grasp in now has been preparing himself for many many lives, in which he could have been of any race, culture or location. That is why I tried to ‘simplify’ the Pali terms and apply them to English, as far as I am able to, of course. And that is only MY understanding.

So I will be ever grateful to Lal here; besides the learning, I have had to UN-learn some things as well.

y not