- This topic has 2 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by
Jittananto.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
November 2, 2025 at 4:34 pm #55512
Jittananto
ParticipantI found a series of suttas that said that someone with these five qualities cannot attain a jhÄna or even the sotÄpanna stage. I was surprised because many of these qualities seem to apply to monks and nuns, but I believe that they also apply to Laypeople. Can Sir Lal or someone see if it is correct? The PaƱcamacchariyasutta states that stinginess with the teaching is the worst. Can Sir Lal explain in detail what this stinginess is and how it blocks the magga phala ?
Mendicants, without giving up these five qualities, you canāt enter and remain in the second absorption ⦠third absorption ⦠fourth absorption ⦠or realize the fruit of stream-entry ⦠the fruit of once-return ⦠the fruit of non-return ⦠perfection.
What five?
Stinginess with dwellings, families, material things, praise, and the teachings.
Without giving up these five qualities, you canāt realize perfection.
But after giving up these five qualities, you can enter and remain in the second absorption ⦠third absorption ⦠fourth absorption ⦠and realize the fruit of stream-entry ⦠the fruit of once-return ⦠the fruit of non-return ⦠perfection.
What five?
Stinginess with dwellings, families, material things, praise, and the teachings.
After giving up these five qualities, you can realize perfection.ā
āPaƱcime, bhikkhave, dhamme appahÄya abhabbo dutiyaį¹ jhÄnaį¹ ā¦pe⦠abhabbo tatiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠abhabbo catutthaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠abhabbo sotÄpattiphalaṠ⦠abhabbo sakadÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠abhabbo anÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠abhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹.Ā Katame paƱca? ÄvÄsamacchariyaį¹, kulamacchariyaį¹, lÄbhamacchariyaį¹, vaį¹į¹amacchariyaį¹, dhammamacchariyaį¹. Ime kho, bhikkhave, paƱca dhamme appahÄya abhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹.
PaƱcime, bhikkhave, dhamme pahÄya bhabbo dutiyaį¹ jhÄnaį¹ ā¦pe⦠bhabbo tatiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠bhabbo catutthaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠bhabbo sotÄpattiphalaṠ⦠bhabbo sakadÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠bhabbo anÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠bhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹. Katame paƱca? ÄvÄsamacchariyaį¹, kulamacchariyaį¹, lÄbhamacchariyaį¹, vaį¹į¹amacchariyaį¹, dhammamacchariyaį¹. Ime kho, bhikkhave, paƱca dhamme pahÄya bhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtunāti.
āMendicants, without giving up these five qualities you canāt enter and remain in the second absorption ⦠third absorption ⦠fourth absorption ⦠or realize the fruit of stream-entry ⦠the fruit of once-return ⦠the fruit of non-return ⦠perfection.
What five?
Stinginess with dwellings, families, material things, praise, and lack of gratitude and thankfulness.
Without giving up these five qualities, you canāt realize perfection.
But after giving up these five qualities, you can enter and remain in the second absorption ⦠third absorption ⦠fourth absorption ⦠and realize the fruit of stream-entry ⦠the fruit of once-return ⦠the fruit of non-return ⦠perfection.
What five?
Stinginess with dwellings, families, material things, praise, and lack of gratitude and thankfulness.
After giving up these five qualities, you can realize perfection.ā
āPaƱcime, bhikkhave, dhamme appahÄya abhabbo dutiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠tatiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠catutthaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠sotÄpattiphalaṠ⦠sakadÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠anÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹. Katame paƱca? ÄvÄsamacchariyaį¹, kulamacchariyaį¹, lÄbhamacchariyaį¹, vaį¹į¹amacchariyaį¹, akataƱƱutaį¹ akataveditaį¹. Ime kho, bhikkhave, paƱca dhamme appahÄya abhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹.
PaƱcime, bhikkhave, dhamme pahÄya bhabbo dutiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠tatiyaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠catutthaį¹ jhÄnaṠ⦠sotÄpattiphalaṠ⦠sakadÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠anÄgÄmiphalaṠ⦠arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtuį¹. Katame paƱca? ÄvÄsamacchariyaį¹, kulamacchariyaį¹, lÄbhamacchariyaį¹, vaį¹į¹amacchariyaį¹, akataƱƱutaį¹ akataveditaį¹. Ime kho, bhikkhave, paƱca dhamme pahÄya bhabbo arahattaį¹ sacchikÄtunāti.
- The sutta starts with the second, but in other ones, the same is said for the first jhÄna. Aparapaį¹hamajhÄnasutta Paį¹hamajhÄnasutta
-
November 2, 2025 at 7:06 pm #55513
Lal
KeymasterThe suttas you quoted are two of a seriesĀ starting with “PaƱcamacchariya Sutta (AN 5.254)” which state the five kinds of extreme greed (macchariya).
- I would translate the five as, “extreme greed for dwellings, family lineage (if born in a ‘high class’ or wealthy family), expensive material possessions, praise and respect from others, and (sharing one’s knowledge of) Dhamma.”
It is a good idea to look at the series of suttas starting with the above.
- The next sutta (AN 5.255) says one must give them up to live a spiritual life.
- The subsequent suttas state one cannot attain any jhanas or magga phala if one doesn’t give them up.
- That makes sense, doesn’t it?
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
November 2, 2025 at 11:08 pm #55514
Jittananto
ParticipantThank you, Sir ššæ. Yes, I understand better with the keyword (extreme greed) you provided.
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.