The need to categorize the 31 realms of this world into kāma loka, rūpa loka, and arūpa loka is discussed. This will clarify why the arising of certain defilements is temporarily blocked while in the realms of rūpa loka or arūpa loka. That information resides in the hadaya vatthu (where thoughts arise) in the manomaya kāya (mental body) of any living being.
November 20, 2026
Three Types of ‘Sub-Worlds’ Within the World
1. We know that the Buddha also categorized the world (loka) into 31 realms. Then, he also placed those 31 realms within three ‘sub-worlds’: kāma loka, rūpa loka, and arūpa loka. What is the need for another categorization?
- The main reason is that the sensory experiences in the three lokas are vastly different. All five physical sensory faculties, i.e., eyes (cakkhu), ears (sōta), nose (ghāna), tongue (jivhā), and physical body (kāya), are missing in the arūpa loka. Only the mind (manō) is present in the 4 Brahma realms of arūpa loka. Thus, they cannot see, hear, taste, smell, ot touch.
- In the 16 Brahma realms of ‘rūpa loka’, they can see and hear in addition to being able to think.
- All five physical sensory faculties and the mind are present in the 11 realms of the ‘kāma loka‘. These realms include the human realm, 6 Deva realms, and the four apāyās (animal, peta, vinipāta asura, and niraya realms).
- All 31 realms and their main properties are listed in “31 Realms of Existence“.
‘Hadaya vatthu‘ – Where Cittās (“Thoughts”) Arise
2. Since all 31 realms have the ability to think, they all have the ‘seat of the mind’ where thoughts (cittās) arise. This is called ‘hadaya vatthu‘ in Abhidhamma.
- The ‘hadaya vatthu‘ is made of a single suddhāṭṭhaka, the ‘smallest material unit’ (comparable in terminology to an atom in modern science; however, it is even smaller than an atom, even smaller than an elementary particle in science).
- In Abhidhamma, all matter in the world is made of suddhāṭṭhaka. Even a tiny grain of sand is made of an unimaginably large number of suddhāṭṭhaka.
- A ‘hadaya vatthu‘ has something extraordinary in addition to the inert suddhāṭṭhaka. It can generate cittās. A ‘hadaya vatthu‘ can arise only through accumulated kammic energy.
- Furthermore, a new ‘hadaya vatthu‘ can arise only to replace a dying ‘hadaya vatthu‘. It is not possible to generate a new hadaya vatthu (i.e., a brand new living being) into the world.
‘Manomaya Kāya‘ – The Essential ‘Kāya‘ of a Living Being
3. Any living being, in any realm, is first ‘born’ with a ‘manomaya kāya‘ or a ‘mental body’.
- Depending on which ‘sub-loka‘ it is born in, the ‘manomaya kāya‘ would also have a number of ‘pasāda rūpa‘ (up to five) that enable sight, hearing, taste, smell, and touch.
- For example, since all five of those sense faculties are present in the ‘kāma loka‘, a living being born in ‘kāma loka‘ will be born with five pasāda rūpa: cakkhu, sota, jivhā, ghāna, and kāya. The mind itself cannot detect those by itself; those sensory inputs must come through the correct pasāda rūpa, or the ‘sense faculty’.
- This is why living beings in ‘arūpa loka‘ (arūpa loka Brahmās) cannot see, hear, taste, smell, or touch anything. They don’t have any pasāda rūpa associated with their ‘manomaya kāya‘.
- Living beings in ‘rūpa loka‘ (rūpa loka Brahmās) can see and hear, but cannot taste, smell, or touch ‘solid matter’. Thus, they only have cakkhu pasāda rūpa and sota pasāda rūpa associated with the manomaya kāya (in addition to the hadaya vatthu, of course).
- Living beings in ‘kāma loka‘ have all five sense faculties. Thus, they have all five types of pasāda rūpa and a hadaya vatthu associated with their manomaya kāya.
The following discussion is restricted to living beings who have not attained a magga phala, i.e., they have all ten samsāric bonds (saṁyojana) intact.
Birth of a New ‘Manomaya Kāya‘
4. The ‘manomaya kāya‘ (with its hadaya vatthu and the applicable number of pasāda rūpa) dies only at the end of that existence, not at the death of the physical body.
- For example, a human’s manomaya kāya may last for many thousands of years. A given human will be reborn with different physical bodies many times during his or her human existence (bhava).
- Only the lifetimes of living beings in the four apāyās and the human realm do not have fixed time spans. All higher Deva and Brahma realms have fixed lifetimes; see the table in “31 Realms of Existence“.
- When the lifetime associated with a given existence (bhava) ends, it will be instantaneously replaced by a new ‘manomaya kāya‘, most likely in another loka.
- For example, consider a human existence ending, and that he/she had cultivated a jhāna. In that case, the person will exit the human existence (bhava) and will be reborn with a ‘manomaya kāya‘ corresponding to that of a ‘rūpa loka Brahma‘. That means the old ‘manomaya kāya‘ (with the human hadaya vattu and five pasāda rūpa) will die, and a new ‘manomaya kāya‘ (with the Brahma hadaya vatthu and two pasāda rūpa) will be born instantaneously. Of course, that new ‘manomaya kāya‘ will appear in the corresponding Brahma realm (in the rūpa loka).
Only Realms Below the Human Realm Have Dense Bodies
5. Brahmās in the rūpa loka and arūpa loka are born with ONLY a manomaya kāya and live their whole lives with that ‘subtle body’. Since a ‘manomaya kāya‘ has only a few suddhāṭṭhaka, they are invisible to us.
- It is unimaginable for us to imagine existence without a physical body, because we can only see humans and animals with solid, physical bodies.
- However, among the 31 realms, the anomaly (unusual aspect) is having a dense, physical body. To form a physical body, the ‘manomaya kāya‘ enters a womb or an egg, resulting in the birth of a dense physical body.
- The Devās in the six Deva realms are born instantaneously with both the’manomaya kāya‘ and a fully-formed physical body. However, that physical body is much less dense than a human or animal physical body. Thus, we can’t see them even if they stand right in front of us.
- Therefore, we wouldn’t be able to observe living beings in most of the 31 realms (those above the human realm), even with the fancy instruments of modern science.
- This is also why one needs to start with ‘amūlikā saddhā‘ (faith not based on facts one can observe for oneself). See #11 of “Dhamma Essentials – Introduction“.
- One must be patient enough to examine the details to see whether the ‘full picture’ makes sense. This is not easy; many people would rather choose the ‘easy way’ of believing in a Creator (sassata diṭṭhi) or that life ends at the death of the physical body (uccheda diṭṭhi).
Physical Bodies Only in a Few Realms of ‘Kāma Loka‘
6. As pointed out above, a human (or an animal) is also born with only the invisible ‘manomaya kāya‘ at the beginning of that existence. That means they are also ‘opapātika‘ births.
- To form a physical body, that ‘manomaya kāya‘ must enter a womb or an egg (for some animals). A human ‘manomaya kāya‘ (also called a ‘gandhabba‘) lives for many thousands of years, during which time the human can be reborn many times with different physical bodies. The parents’ bodies influence that physical body, and the same human is ‘reborn’ many times with different-looking physical bodies. See “Buddhist Explanations of Conception, Abortion, and Contraception”.
- Therefore, a human also lives with only the ‘manomaya kāya‘ (‘gandhabba‘) in between lives with solid, physical bodies.
- The same applies to animals. In between womb-born (or egg-born) physical bodies, many animals live with just the ‘manomaya kāya‘.
Need for a Physical Body in Kāma Loka
7. The need for the physical body is simple: Without a physical body, it is impossible to experience taste, smell, and touch.
- A living being in the kāma loka that craves optimum sensory fulfillment requires all five sense faculties other than the mind.
- One can look at an object from a distance. One can hear sound from a distant source. Thus, one can experience sights and sounds from a distance.
- However, taste, smell, and touch require ‘close physical contact’. To taste, the food must come into contact with the tongue; to smell an odor, the odor particles must enter the nose; to make sexual contact, one must physically touch another.
- Even though a ‘human gandhabba‘ has all five types of pasāda rūpa, the three involving taste, smell, and touch are useless without a physical body. However, it can see and hear with only the pasāda rūpa (i.e., with only the manomaya kāya).
Drawbacks/Dangers of Having a Physical Body
8. Therefore, to get the ‘full sensory experience,’ the gandhabba, or the ‘manomaya kāya,’ requires a dense physical body.
- The problem is that such a dense physical body is subjected to old age, disease, and death.
- It cannot even last the ‘lifetime associated with human existence or bhava’. As we have discussed, a human existence (i.e., the ‘manomaya kāya‘) can last for many thousands of years. Yet, after being born with a physical body, that physical body lasts only about a hundred years. That death (within the human existence itself) is a cause of suffering; everyone knows that it is inevitable, and one would have to leave one’s loved ones and all the wealth one has acquired behind. That is one drawback of a physical body.
- Some ancient yogis also understood another, deeper drawback of being born with a physical body: one must make an effort to provide food to sustain it and also seek ways to provide different types of ‘pleasure-generating sensory inputs’ to it. For example, eating only to sustain the body is not enough for most people; one seeks a wide variety of delicious foods. One would seek sexual pleasure (sexual intercourse), but even that is not enough. One would want to watch movies with attractive actors/actresses, etc.; i.e., all five sense faculties are used for ‘optimum sensory experience’.
- When engaging in such ways of ‘seeking sensual pleasures’, it is inevitable that one would engage in stealing, lying, and even killing others. That generates kammic energies which lead to rebirths in the apāyās. Thus, one would acquire enough kammic energy within a single hundred-year lifespan to be reborn in various apāyās for millions of years; that is because once born in an apāya, it is not easy to get back to a ‘good realm’. This is a crucial fact to understand.
Akusala Kamma Generation Is Predominant in the Human Realm and the Apāyās
9. It is mostly those living beings in the human realm and the four realms below it (apāyās) who engage in akusala kamma.
- First, in the 20 realms belonging to the rūpa loka or the arūpa loka, there are absolutely no sensual pleasures involving sex or other bodily contacts, foods, or fragrances. They live solitary lives and don’t seek contact with other Brahmās. They do not have males and females, and of course all births are ‘opapātika births’ with only the manomaya kāya born instantaneously.
- Therefore, there is no need to steal, lie, or kill (with kāya saṅkhāra), or even have immoral thoughts (vaci saṅkhāra). Even though they have micchā diṭṭhi, they do not get any of the akusala that can generate kammic energy to be reborn in an apāya.
- Since they have not comprehended Buddha Dhamma, they are unable to generate any kusala kamma either.
- Thus, during that lifetime, they enjoy only “jhāna or samāpatti sukha.” At the end of that time, they return to the human realm. It is like taking a ‘good vacation’. They have not added any new kammic energy, nor have they made any progress toward terminating the rebirth process.
10. The case of the Devās in the six Deva realms above the human realm is not clear-cut.
- They are still in the kāma loka, and thus still crave sensory pleasures via all six sense faculties.
- However, they automatically receive the pleasures they seek. There is no need to engage in the three types of ‘kāya kamma‘ (stealing, lying, and killing) or vaci kamma (lying, harsh speech, divisive speech, or gossiping). There are not many situations where abhijjā (subtle greed) or paṭigha (dislike), or micchā diṭṭhi, can arise, even though it cannot be ruled out.
- Thus, Devās are almost like the Brahmās, in the sense of not accumulating new kammic energies. However, it is not guaranteed.
How Are Brahmās Prevented from Engaging in Akusala Kamma?
11. Thus, Brahmās in the 20 realms of rūpa loka and arūpa loka are virtually immune from accumulating new kammic energies that can bring rebirths.
- How are they prevented from engaging in akusala kamma even though they have not eliminated even a single saṁyojana (bonds to the rebirth process)?
- All that information (which defilements are temporarily suppressed) resides in the hadaya vatthu (where thoughts arise) in the manomaya kāya (mental body) of those Brahmās.
- Specifically, kāma rāga cannot arise in them. Most akusala kamma are done with kāma rāga.
- We will discuss this more in the next post.
They Are Still Capable of Attaining Magga Phala
12. However, Brahmās in rūpa loka and Devās in the six realms of kāma loka are fully capable of comprehending the Buddha’s teachings. Thus, if they get to listen to a Noble Person, they have the capability to attain magga phala.
- Especially in the time of a living Buddha, many Brahmās and Devās attain various stages of magga phala.
- Also, note that the Buddha called Brahmās and Devās collectively ‘Devās‘ in some cases. They all have ‘Deva gati‘. Note that ‘gati‘ is pronounced ‘gathi’. See “Pāli Words – Writing and Pronunciation”.
- The Buddha divided all existences into five main categories based on predominant gati. The “Gati Sutta (AN 9.68)” lists those five main categories: Hell (niraya), the animal realm (tiracchāna), the hungry ghost realm (peta), humans (manussa), and Deva. Many suttās (including Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta) sometimes lump the Devās in the six Deva realms and Brahmās in 20 Brahma realms into one category as Devās.
Human Realm Is Unique
13. This is why the human realm is special.
- It is a human who has the ability to cultivate all five main gati listed in the Gati Sutta, and also attain a magga phala.
- Unlike the Brahmās and Devās, humans can see enough suffering around them to feel motivated to learn Buddha Dhamma.
- However, some humans (those who are healthy and wealthy) may not be able to generate that motivation.
- Even in the days before the Buddha, relatively few humans are able to figure out the dangers of attaching to sensual pleasures.
- Furthermore, a Buddha is born only in the human realm.
Dangers of Sensual Pleasures Can Be Understood Even Without a Buddha
14. Ancient yogis like Ālāra Kālama and Uddaka Rāmaputta fully realized those dangers associated with existence in the kāma loka.
- They also realized that when one abstains from seeking such ‘temporary sensual pleasures’, one can separate from the ‘human mindset’ and enter jhānās, which correspond to the mindset of rūpa loka Brahmās.
- They also realized that when one is fully absorbed in a jhāna, one is temporarily ‘detached’ from the physical body. When this happens, one is in a ‘jhāna samāpatti‘ where the mind becomes totally detached from the ‘kāma loka‘.
- For example, if one is in the ‘jhāna samāpatti‘ corresponding to the first jhāna, it is as if one is living in a ‘rūpa loka Brahma realm’ corresponding to it (Brahma Pārisajja Deva, Brahma Purohita Deva, or Brahmakāyika Deva). The first jhāna has three levels: weak, middle, and highest (hīna, majjhimā, paṇīta), which correspond to the first three ‘rūpa loka Brahma realms’. See the table in “31 Realms of Existence“.
- Any human who has cultivated such jhāna will be reborn in the corresponding Brahma realm upon death. The highest Brahma realm corresponding to the first jhāna (Brahmakāyika realm) is where the ‘Mahā Brahma‘ in Hinduism lives; see the table in “31 Realms of Existence“.
- We discussed “Mahā Brahma” in the previous post, “Dhamma Essentials – Introduction“.
Cultivating Jhāna Is Not Easy
15. To cultivate a jhāna, one must first abstain from akusala kamma (‘vivicceva akusalehi dhammehi‘). Then, one must abstain from activities seeking sensual pleasures (‘vivicceva kāmehi‘). Fulfilling both those conditions is almost impossible while living a normal life in society. That is why ancient yogis went deep into jungles.
- Even that is not enough to attain even an anariya jhāna. To keep ‘sensual thoughts’ from coming to mind, they focus on a ‘neutral object’ such as a kasina object. The easiest is to focus on one’s own breath. We call that ‘breath meditation’ today. It is not really a meditation; it is not an ‘insight meditation’. It is a mechanical process.
- That is essentially how one cultivates anariya jhāna.
- As one cultivates higher anariya jhāna, one can access the mindsets of higher Brahma realms. The second and third jhānās correspond to the next six Brahma realms. The fourth jhāna corresponds to the Vehappala Deva realm (the Buddha frequently called Brahmās as Devās); see the table in “31 Realms of Existence“.
Arūpa Samāpatti: Even More Difficult to Attain
16. When one has optimally cultivated the fourth anariya jhāna, one’s mind is ready to separate from the rūpa loka.
- In the first realm of the arūpa loka (Ākāsānancāyatana), the mind is focused solely on the ‘infinite space’. It is totally separated from the ‘rūpa loka,’ and no pasāda rūpa is active; only the hadaya vatthu is active.
- To reach it, a yogi in the fourth anariya jhāna focuses his mind on the ‘infinite space,’ constantly repeating “infinite space, infinite space…”. That would release his mind from the rūpa loka and enter the first realm in the arūpa loka.
- Now, infinite viññāṇa is also ‘attached’ to the infinite space (this is how kamma vipaka can materialize anywhere instantly), but can be separated from space. By focusing the mind on that, the yogi can next enter Viññāṇañcāyatana (the second realm in arūpa loka) by separating infinite viññāṇa from infinite space.
- Viññāṇa itself is mind-made and can be shrunk. That leads to the third realm, Ākiñcaññāyatana.
- Then that viññāṇa can be shrunk almost to the non-existent level, and correspondingly, saññā can be shrunk almost to the non-existent level. This is the highest realm an anariya yogi can access, the Nevasaññānāsaññāyatana (neva saññā na asañña āyatana) or a state with ‘almost no saññā‘.
A Yogi in the Highest Arūpa Realm Is Not Released from Rebirths in Apāyās
17. However, since the yogi has not eliminated any saṁyojana (or avijjā), they can never reach a state without any ‘lokiya saññā‘. That is because they have not ‘seen’ the anicca, dukkha, anatta nature of the world (equivalently, the Four Noble Truths) to break the ten saṁyojana (bonds to the rebirth process).
- As we will see in upcoming posts, avijjā cannot be eliminated, and breaking the saṁyojana is not possible until one’s mind enters the Satipaṭṭhāna Bhūmi.
- I have already discussed that in many posts (see, for example, “Satipaṭṭhāna Bhūmi – Free of Loka Saññā“), but I will approach it differently in this series.
- The connection between the three types of loka and the corresponding bhava is discussed in “Big Picture – Three Types of Bhava“.
18. Thus, an anariya yogi who reaches even the highest arūpa realm is not released from future rebirths in the apāyās. At the end of that lifetime, they return first to the human realm and then start the whole process again. Each of us (or even a living being in an apāya now) may have even gotten to that state many times in the ‘beginningless rebirth process’. This is why it is called the ‘cycle of rebirth’!
- Even though this is a relatively long post, I thought it would be good to share all that information about the 31 realms separated into three ‘sub-worlds’ (kāma loka, rūpa loka, and arūpa loka) in one coherent essay. It is necessary to understand why greed and anger (and the ability to engage in akusala kamma) are temporarily suppressed in many of the 31 realms. That explains the importance of breaking saṁsāric bonds (saṁyojana) by understanding the Buddha’s wider worldview to end future suffering permanently.
- As we saw above, the variety of ‘distorted saññā‘ decreases from the kāma loka to the arūpa loka. Then just one type of ‘distorted saññā‘ is left in the arūpa loka, and even that is almost stopped at the highest arūpa realm. However, since avijjā has not been removed at all (ignorance about the defilement-generation process is not understood even at the Sotāpanna stage), the rebirth process among the 31 realms will continue for them!
- One attains the Sotāpanna stage of Nibbāna by comprehending the details of the above-discussed wider worldview of the Buddha. See “Sotāpanna Stage – Essential and Unnecessary Concepts“.
- An essential ‘background’ is how different types of ‘built-in distorted saññā‘ affect the mind of living beings in kāma, rūpa, and arūpa loka. We will cover a bit more background in the next post before getting to that critical point.
Posts in the new Series: “Dhamma Essentials”
All recent posts: “New / Revised Posts”