April 28, 2026 at 7:41 am
#57215
Keymaster
It is unfortunate that you have such ingrained wrong views. You cannot see a contradiction when presented clearly. Let me try another way.
- Your main position, on which you base your assumptions about breath, is the following: (i) Kāyānupassanā as ‘contemplation of the body.’ (ii) Assāsapass = In-breathing and out-breathing.” (iii) Without getting started with Kāyānupassanā (as defined above), one cannot attain any magga phala.
1. Do Brahmas in rupa lokas have ‘physical bodies’ that they can contemplate on? Can they engage in ānāpāna (In-breathing and out-breathing)?
- According to your assumptions, they cannot attain any magga phala because they do not have dense physical bodies with body parts to contemplate on. They can only see, hear, and think. No taste, smell, ot touch sensations, and no breathing!
- P.S. Even Devas (especially in the higher realms) do not have decaying body parts to contemplate on. We do not know whether they breathe as we do. But they don’t get sick or have decaying body parts until close to the end of their long lives.
2. Yet, it is well known that rupa loka Buhamas in 15 realms there (except in the asanna realm) can attain all magga phala.
- The “Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta (SN 56.11)” itself states that rupa loka Buhamas also came to listen to the Buddha’s first discourse.
_________
Do you see that obvious contradiction?